• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Development
  • Food+Drink
  • Things To Do
  • Doing Good
  • Lifestyle
  • Arts
  • History
  • Lists

Daily Detroit

What To Know And Where To Go In Southeast Michigan

Header Right

  • PODCAST
  • NEWSLETTER
  • SUPPORT
  • ARCHIVE
  • CONTACT
  • LISTEN ON:
  • APPLE PODCASTS
  • SPOTIFY
  • GOOGLE PODCASTS
  • STITCHER
  • Submit An Idea To Daily Detroit
  • Get Your Daily Detroit Newsletter
  • Listen To The Daily Detroit Podcast
  • Contact Us
  • LISTEN ON:
  • APPLE PODCASTS
  • SPOTIFY
  • GOOGLE PODCASTS
  • STITCHER
Police cruiser in Detroit (Daily Detroit File Photo)

OPINION: I Am The Wife Of A White Cop Who Polices A Black Neighborhood In Detroit

You are here: Home / Opinion / OPINION: I Am The Wife Of A White Cop Who Polices A Black Neighborhood In Detroit

Dec 14, 2014 by Kristin Van Raaphorst

My husband and I both work in public service in different capacities. My career is in the nonprofit sector; his is in law enforcement. We both work in Detroit. A few years ago, I represented my then-organization at a “Communities in Action Annual Convening” held by the Kellogg Foundation. The summit included several breakout sessions with groups strategically assembled to promote productive dialogue. A response to a focus question in my group prompted me to ask, “But isn’t the assignment of values to an entire set of people, by sole virtue of common physical traits, the definition of racism?” The man responded, “Not MY definition of racism.” I’ve considered the concept of race relations completely differently ever since. Now that I am married to a police officer, that experience has been further inlaid.

kvrMy husband and I have had hours-long discussions about the events surrounding Michael Brown, Tamir Rice, Akai Gurley, Eric Garner, and others both contemporary and historic. We’ve talked at length about all that can go wrong on facially benign runs, the compulsory paranoia instilled in police during their training, arm-chair quarterbacking and the distressing lack of transparency in the grand jury process. I have (probably unfairly) asked him to defend the most well-intentioned scenarios he could dream up, to give even a shred of “two sides” to what I was seeing. My husband is a good man and a good officer. He is also an obviously white cop in a predominantly black neighborhood, so I have evident concerns for his well-being and safety. This is a climate where widespread outrage is focused on police officers as state actors, with specific attention on those who have the appearance of being white; I do worry that his features could lead to unfair (and unfounded) assumptions. This is not, however, a plea for white guys or a defense of the police institution. I just don’t believe we’re looking at the problem broadly enough.

The current conversations on “fixing” various systems only go so far to acknowledge the depth of the challenge. Because the most recent events are both mired in tragedy and involve state agency implements versus black members of our society, it is easiest to insist that policing itself is the rotten root; or to ferret out flaws in the men and boys who were killed. There are those who would vehemently insist that the results of these incidences are specific to their principals, and while that could be partially true, it doesn’t address a distinctly probable cause originating in our American social tapestry: we are traditionally taught to fear each other, whether we say it out loud or not.

We continue to pass down some deeply race-based beliefs by reaction alone. Maybe a mother does not tell her children that black men are dangerous, but her children subconsciously learn if she stiffens and quiets in the sudden presence of a black man. That same mother may even make a conscious point to impart inclusive life lessons regarding human equality, but physical cues are powerful: her children will absorb her fear responses. Their children will learn as well, just as the children of those taught that they must necessarily fear the police will have the same reactions. I felt this from my own parents growing up, and I know this to be true of many others from hushed conversations in the shadows of years. Stigma avoidance is an effective muffler.

Attempts at solutions to racial issues have largely centered on access and integration, with hope that granted passage will imply value and lead to changes in perception on both sides. But addressing the issue of fear is not the same as recognizing worth in differing subsets (nor is it the same as addressing hate). Certainly there have been some exceptional efforts in rift-bridging through education and celebrations of cultures; the recognition of tradition and beauty is important. But appreciation and fear are not mutually exclusive; volcanoes and lightning storms are brilliant but also signal danger and the necessity of distance.

How do we teach people that their wary gaze is not fixed upon lightning storms at all, but something much more approachable in nature? There has to be a comprehension that bright lights don’t equal tempests, and it must go beyond simply declaring that we understand. Our bodies betray us as humans, and in the deepest moments of fight or flight they can prove fatal on a false assumption. This is true of both private citizens and those who have taken the oath to enforce the law. Constance Rice spoke eloquently on this with NPR’s “Code Switch.”

Until we can discuss how to deconstruct a prejudicial fear trigger, there is no chance to approach complete objectivity. Certainly the fact that police officers are sanctioned to exercise elevated power necessitates a deep look at how they are taught to wield it. But what if their brains/bodies are initiating protocols in response to generationally-programmed threats, provoked by set of physical traits, logically unrelated to a person’s proclivity to do violence? That rightfully delegitimizes the “fear for your life” standard. If a person is trained in force techniques to be used at his or her judgment, then functional discretion must also be taught. Here’s something I learned during the last several weeks: a large amount of available police training is optional, not mandatory. A lot of training is also considered complete by sending communiques and assuming they are read and understood by officers.

So when departments say they are “training” officers in diffusion tactics, application of judgment, and/or community relations, I think it is important to ask those departments what “training” really means, and how that should change in the light of modern day. But to the heart of the heart, the root of the root: it is to what (and how) we are conditioned to respond, long before we choose our careers, that most deeply impacts our ability to access any sort of training in moments of panic. Not all future officers are going to be the sons and daughters of current officers; diluting potential latent fears within the ranks of officers is important, but so too must they be addressed in our homes: ALL of our homes. Many triggers are buried deep in the unwillingness to regard their existence, only to surface in moments of limbic hijack.

I do not mean to suggest that all white persons are afraid of black persons or vice versa, or that all black persons are afraid of the police, or that all cops have good intentions and are merely unaware of their own latent prejudices. The answer is not as simple as a blanket statement and cannot be all inclusive any more than motive for choosing a job. I do believe, however, that this is a substantial and neglected piece of a puzzle that would impact communities — and their police departments — in a profound way, if treated as relevant and worthy of conversation. Much of this is hearsay, that’s true; but so is most of what has shaped societies for generations. And in Detroit, hearsay is admissible in grand jury proceedings.

Ed. Note: This post is the opinion of Kristin Van Raaphorst and does not necessarily reflect the views of Daily Detroit. It is shared here to push the conversation forward and be a platform for those interested in Detroit. We welcome your comments and feedback. If you’d like to submit something for us to consider publishing, check out our submit form.

FacebookTweetLinkedInEmail

Filed Under: Opinion, Staff Picks Tagged With: #ICantBreathe, black men, Detroit, Police in Detroit, White cops

Be In The Know In About 20 Minutes A Day

“Thanks for your excellent coverage! Daily Detroit is part of my morning routine and as a lifelong metro area resident I appreciate your focus.”

– Jessica

Be like Jessica and keep up on the news, stories, and people that are pushing the Motor City forward on the Daily Detroit podcast. Free in your podcast app of choice:

Apple logoGoogle logoSpotify logoAmazon logoPocketcasts logoStitcher logoOvercast logoIheartradio logoRss logo
Previous Post: «Punch Bowl Social Beverage Director Patrick Williams Two Minutes With Punch Bowl Social Beverage Director Patrick Williams
Next Post: DTE Energy Completes Renovation Of Art Deco Building Downtown »

Primary Sidebar

Support the businesses & orgs that keep us on the air!

Fusion Marketing

Media funded by listeners serves our listeners. Become a member, get swag!

Support this podcast

PODCAST: The End Of Auto Shows As We Knew Them Plus NACTOY Winners w/ Eric Trytko

PODCAST: 7 Things To Know Around Metro Detroit

PODCAST: WTF Happened in Washington w/ Steve Friess

PODCAST: 7 Things To Know Around Metro Detroit

PODCAST: College players can get paid in Michigan; Free beer for Lions fans and more w/ Fletcher Sharpe

PODCAST: The Real Story of Detroit’s “Fist” – The Monument to Joe Louis

PODCAST: 3 Things To Know Plus Sports w/ Fletcher Sharpe

PODCAST: Big Sean And The Pistons, Detroit City FC News, Three Lions Go To Pro Bowl w/ Fletcher Sharpe

Beating Coronavirus For Christmas – A Miracle for Mom

PODCAST: Why We Should Save The Bandshell On The State Fairgrounds Amazon Site

Get our newsletter covering what to know & where to go in Metro Detroit in your inbox!


Footer

Popular Topics

Belle Isle Brush Park Business Cars CBD City 5 City Of Detroit Corktown Crowdfunding Culture Development Doing Good Eastern Market East Riverfront Education Events Featured Ferndale Food + Drink Fun Green Hamtramck History Lifestyle Lists Macomb County Midtown New Center News Newsflash Oakland County Opinion Podcasts Policy Royal Oak Shopping Southwest Detroit Sports Staff Picks Tech Things To Do Transit University District Video Wayne County

On Social Media

Visit Us On TwitterVisit Us On InstagramVisit Us On FacebookVisit Us On LinkedinCheck Our FeedVisit Us On Youtube
  • Submit An Idea To Daily Detroit
  • Get Your Daily Detroit Newsletter
  • Listen To The Daily Detroit Podcast
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2021 · Daily Detroit · 1420 Washington Blvd, Suite 301 · Detroit, MI 48226

Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!