> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.dailydetroit.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# How to Make Detroit More Affordable (w/ Steve Watson)
- URL: https://www.dailydetroit.com/episodes/how-to-make-detroit-more-affordable-w-steve-watson/
- Published: 2026-11-19T19:57:35.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T22:26:44.000Z
- Author: Jer Staes
- Tags: #audio, Politics and Policy, civics, Detroit housing trends, Steve Watson, land value tax

How to Make Detroit More Affordable (w/ Steve Watson)

0:00

/1263

1×

We like to talk about solutions at Daily Detroit. Today, we talk about a three-part property tax reform roadmap that combines a land value tax, a major-event ticket fee, and a fair share of internet gaming revenue, that could cut Detroit homeowners' tax bills roughly in half.

Detroit homeowners pay some of the highest property tax rates in the country — roughly 6.4% of a home's value every year — while out-of-state land speculators pay pennies on vacant lots that cost the city millions to maintain.

Former Detroit Deputy CFO Steve Watson (partner at Watson & Yates and author of The Balanced Sheet Substack) joins me at TechTown to lay out a concrete, three-pronged roadmap to cut Detroit's property taxes by more than half without gutting city services or schools, saving thousands for Detroiters.

Read Steve Watson's full proposal on The Balanced Sheet Substack and on Watson & Yates: https://watsonyates.com

Support Daily Detroit on Patreon (help us hit our 2,000th episode goal!): https://patreon.com/dailydetroit

Send feedback or questions: dailydetroit@gmail.com or 313-789-3211.

```chapters
00:00:00 Introduction to Detroit Affordability
00:01:21 Detroit's High Property Tax Burden
00:02:15 Financial Impact on Local Homeowners
00:04:09 Comparing Detroit and Grand Rapids Taxes
00:05:08 Proposal One Major Event Ticket Tax
00:07:13 Proposal Two Fair Share of iGaming Revenue
00:09:04 Proposal Three Implementing Land Value Tax
00:11:21 How Tax Reform Protects Homeowners
00:14:27 Targeting Unmovable Assets for Tax Revenue
00:16:03 Legislative Steps Required in Lansing
```

```vtt
WEBVTT

00:00:00.359 --> 00:00:02.535
Daily<00:00:00.605> Detroit<00:00:00.997> is<00:00:01.095> brought<00:00:01.341> to<00:00:01.504> you<00:00:01.832> by<00:00:01.930> the<00:00:02.061> community.

00:00:02.911 --> 00:00:04.416
Support<00:00:03.287> our<00:00:03.451> work<00:00:03.516> at<00:00:03.614> patreon.com/dailydetroit.

00:00:10.057 --> 00:00:16.025
Hello<00:00:12.234> friends,<00:00:12.493> welcome<00:00:12.815> to<00:00:12.976> your<00:00:13.364> Daily<00:00:13.622> Detroit,<00:00:13.944> sharing<00:00:14.251> what<00:00:14.428> to<00:00:14.509> know<00:00:14.670> and<00:00:14.815> where<00:00:14.928> to<00:00:15.057> go<00:00:15.235> in<00:00:15.315> Southeast<00:00:15.719> Michigan.

00:00:16.452 --> 00:00:22.416
I<00:00:16.614> am<00:00:16.841> JR<00:00:17.181> Stays,<00:00:17.586> coming<00:00:17.894> to<00:00:17.975> you<00:00:18.478> from<00:00:18.705> our<00:00:18.883> beautiful<00:00:19.288> studio<00:00:19.856> at<00:00:20.082> TechTown<00:00:20.585> in<00:00:20.666> the<00:00:20.828> heart<00:00:21.217> of<00:00:21.460> the<00:00:21.493> Motor<00:00:21.979> City.

00:00:23.478 --> 00:00:30.723
Joining<00:00:23.901> me<00:00:24.210> at<00:00:24.308> the<00:00:24.389> table<00:00:24.877> is<00:00:25.039> a<00:00:25.120> recurring<00:00:25.852> guest<00:00:26.405> who,<00:00:26.811> uh,<00:00:26.990> today<00:00:27.380> we're<00:00:27.478> really<00:00:27.657> going<00:00:27.819> to<00:00:27.868> talk<00:00:28.128> about<00:00:28.576> How<00:00:28.736> to<00:00:28.816> make<00:00:29.233> Detroit<00:00:29.858> more<00:00:30.114> affordable.

00:00:30.820 --> 00:00:36.366
While<00:00:31.012> we<00:00:31.156> get<00:00:31.381> nerdy<00:00:31.637> with<00:00:31.797> the<00:00:31.862> numbers,<00:00:32.695> Steve<00:00:33.000> Watson,<00:00:33.865> partner<00:00:34.346> at<00:00:34.603> Watson<00:00:35.388> and<00:00:35.965> Yates.

00:00:36.510 --> 00:00:37.921
Welcome<00:00:36.927> back<00:00:37.167> to<00:00:37.247> Daily<00:00:37.488> Detroit.

00:00:38.674 --> 00:00:39.011
Thanks,<00:00:38.850> Jer.

00:00:39.075 --> 00:00:39.652
Happy<00:00:39.267> to<00:00:39.331> be<00:00:39.475> here.

00:00:40.036 --> 00:00:54.671
Yeah,<00:00:40.309> so<00:00:41.014> you<00:00:41.110> have<00:00:41.271> a<00:00:41.335> new,<00:00:41.720> uh,<00:00:41.816> piece<00:00:42.152> up<00:00:42.361> on<00:00:42.457> your<00:00:42.617> Substack,<00:00:43.339> a<00:00:43.483> roadmap<00:00:43.996> for<00:00:44.156> Detroit<00:00:44.685> property<00:00:45.022> tax<00:00:45.262> reform,<00:00:45.663> but<00:00:45.759> I'm<00:00:45.903> really<00:00:46.144> going<00:00:46.224> to<00:00:46.304> frame<00:00:46.625> it<00:00:46.705> in<00:00:47.089> a<00:00:47.170> way<00:00:47.410> that's<00:00:47.666> more<00:00:47.827> about<00:00:48.853> how<00:00:49.253> do<00:00:49.430> we<00:00:49.975> actually<00:00:50.391> do<00:00:50.616> the<00:00:50.776> work<00:00:51.353> of<00:00:51.578> making<00:00:52.379> Detroit<00:00:52.956> more<00:00:53.293> affordable<00:00:53.838> for<00:00:54.158> Detroiters.

00:00:54.719 --> 00:00:57.624
And<00:00:54.783> I<00:00:54.880> think<00:00:55.040> there's<00:00:55.216> a<00:00:55.280> lot<00:00:55.457> of<00:00:55.938> theories<00:00:56.708> and<00:00:56.869> talk<00:00:57.270> out<00:00:57.447> there.

00:00:58.089 --> 00:01:08.333
But<00:00:58.394> with<00:00:58.555> your<00:00:58.699> experience<00:00:59.213> being<00:00:59.438> a<00:00:59.470> former,<00:01:00.401> uh,<00:01:00.498> Deputy<00:01:00.755> CFO<00:01:01.220> for<00:01:01.333> the<00:01:01.397> City<00:01:01.702> of<00:01:01.766> Detroit,<00:01:02.569> working<00:01:02.826> with<00:01:02.986> a<00:01:03.003> number<00:01:03.693> of<00:01:04.271> governmental<00:01:04.913> entities<00:01:05.299> over<00:01:05.539> years<00:01:05.780> also,<00:01:06.021> that's<00:01:06.182> professionally<00:01:06.663> what<00:01:06.824> you<00:01:06.904> do,<00:01:07.001> you're<00:01:07.161> an<00:01:07.241> actual<00:01:07.547> expert<00:01:07.884> in<00:01:07.964> this<00:01:08.157> stuff.

00:01:09.393 --> 00:01:20.536
Let's<00:01:09.794> unpack<00:01:10.389> some<00:01:10.597> of<00:01:10.678> your<00:01:10.934> thoughts<00:01:11.657> and<00:01:11.737> kind<00:01:11.866> of<00:01:11.898> like<00:01:12.123> what<00:01:12.283> the<00:01:12.380> challenge<00:01:13.006> is<00:01:13.664> and<00:01:13.744> what<00:01:13.905> the<00:01:14.130> opportunities<00:01:14.933> are,<00:01:15.109> especially<00:01:15.655> as<00:01:15.751> we're<00:01:15.848> heading<00:01:16.137> into<00:01:16.715> a<00:01:16.731> new<00:01:16.956> statewide<00:01:17.453> administration,<00:01:18.561> a<00:01:18.738> new<00:01:19.107> year,<00:01:19.589> all<00:01:19.766> kinds<00:01:20.167> of<00:01:20.247> things.

00:01:21.195 --> 00:01:27.023
Uh,<00:01:21.355> and<00:01:21.452> kind<00:01:21.628> of<00:01:21.676> like,<00:01:22.238> let's<00:01:22.399> start<00:01:22.640> with<00:01:23.041> what<00:01:23.202> is<00:01:23.378> the<00:01:23.523> problem<00:01:24.021> and<00:01:24.181> what<00:01:24.342> is<00:01:24.486> driving<00:01:24.904> a<00:01:24.984> lot<00:01:25.161> of<00:01:25.385> unaffordability<00:01:26.252> for<00:01:26.413> Detroiters<00:01:26.895> right<00:01:26.991> now?

00:01:27.713 --> 00:01:34.012
Yeah,<00:01:27.873> so<00:01:28.194> Detroit<00:01:28.658> has<00:01:29.380> one<00:01:29.476> of<00:01:29.556> the<00:01:29.620> highest<00:01:30.037> property<00:01:30.422> tax<00:01:30.742> rates<00:01:30.999> in<00:01:31.063> the<00:01:31.143> state<00:01:31.400> of<00:01:31.432> Michigan<00:01:32.826> and<00:01:32.922> even<00:01:33.099> across<00:01:33.483> the<00:01:33.564> country.

00:01:34.750 --> 00:01:43.711
Right<00:01:34.926> now,<00:01:35.247> Detroit<00:01:35.952> across<00:01:36.433> all<00:01:36.593> jurisdictions<00:01:37.315> levies<00:01:37.587> 64<00:01:38.389> mills,<00:01:39.318> and<00:01:39.399> what<00:01:39.559> that<00:01:39.799> means<00:01:40.360> is<00:01:40.697> basically<00:01:41.034> 6.4%<00:01:42.524> on<00:01:42.685> the<00:01:42.717> value<00:01:43.086> of<00:01:43.182> your<00:01:43.262> property.

00:01:44.464 --> 00:01:48.808
That<00:01:45.250> is<00:01:45.506> both<00:01:45.747> the,<00:01:46.067> the<00:01:46.147> city,<00:01:46.708> the<00:01:46.788> schools,<00:01:47.510> the<00:01:47.654> county,<00:01:48.215> and<00:01:48.295> the<00:01:48.392> library.

00:01:48.872 --> 00:02:02.069
The<00:01:48.969> city<00:01:49.129> is<00:01:49.257> about<00:01:49.498> a<00:01:49.658> third<00:01:50.075> of<00:01:50.219> that<00:01:50.475> tax<00:01:50.876> bill,<00:01:51.742> and<00:01:52.062> the<00:01:52.159> reason<00:01:52.463> it's<00:01:52.559> so<00:01:52.784> high<00:01:53.361> and<00:01:53.505> has<00:01:53.681> been<00:01:53.826> for<00:01:54.002> decades,<00:01:54.948> we've<00:01:55.044> been<00:01:55.204> trapped<00:01:55.461> in<00:01:55.589> the<00:01:55.621> cycle<00:01:56.086> of<00:01:56.230> squeezing<00:01:56.823> as<00:01:56.968> much<00:01:57.272> revenue<00:01:57.673> as<00:01:57.769> possible<00:01:58.491> out<00:01:58.651> of<00:01:58.971> a<00:01:59.677> a<00:01:59.694> small<00:02:00.175> and<00:02:00.335> previously<00:02:00.977> declining<00:02:01.459> tax<00:02:01.844> base.

00:02:02.502 --> 00:02:11.457
In<00:02:02.807> the<00:02:02.983> decades<00:02:03.401> since,<00:02:04.412> the<00:02:04.508> tax<00:02:04.749> base<00:02:04.893> has<00:02:05.070> grown,<00:02:05.856> but<00:02:05.952> we've<00:02:06.097> been<00:02:06.273> locked<00:02:06.594> into<00:02:06.755> this<00:02:06.979> really<00:02:07.220> high<00:02:07.461> property<00:02:07.798> tax<00:02:08.199> rate<00:02:09.001> to<00:02:09.097> sustain<00:02:09.547> public<00:02:09.804> services<00:02:10.365> and<00:02:10.510> investment<00:02:10.911> in<00:02:10.991> our<00:02:11.087> schools.

00:02:11.745 --> 00:02:14.233
So<00:02:11.890> what<00:02:12.050> does<00:02:12.195> that<00:02:12.435> mean<00:02:12.917> on<00:02:13.093> the<00:02:13.174> ground<00:02:13.495> for<00:02:13.719> a<00:02:13.735> homeowner?

00:02:15.180 --> 00:02:25.707
So<00:02:15.485> what<00:02:15.581> it<00:02:15.661> means<00:02:15.966> is<00:02:16.704> based<00:02:17.009> on<00:02:17.105> the<00:02:17.908> value<00:02:18.245> of<00:02:18.373> your<00:02:18.469> home,<00:02:19.015> you<00:02:19.111> would<00:02:19.272> pay<00:02:19.673> 6.4%<00:02:21.518> each<00:02:21.823> year<00:02:22.626> on<00:02:23.284> the<00:02:23.444> tax<00:02:23.749> bill<00:02:23.829> you<00:02:23.926> get<00:02:24.070> from<00:02:24.231> the<00:02:24.263> city,<00:02:24.648> both<00:02:24.872> in<00:02:24.905> the<00:02:24.985> summer<00:02:25.290> and<00:02:25.370> the<00:02:25.434> winter.

00:02:26.120 --> 00:02:29.916
So<00:02:26.950> let's<00:02:27.195> work<00:02:27.374> that<00:02:27.537> math<00:02:27.847> out<00:02:28.172> as<00:02:28.352> more<00:02:28.515> than<00:02:28.678> percentage<00:02:29.313> points,<00:02:29.737> right?

00:02:29.981 --> 00:02:34.472
So<00:02:30.551> let's<00:02:30.828> say<00:02:30.959> there's<00:02:31.203> like<00:02:31.382> a<00:02:31.447> $70,000<00:02:32.700> place<00:02:33.054> in<00:02:33.135> like<00:02:33.537> Pingree<00:02:33.924> Park<00:02:34.182> or<00:02:34.247> something.

00:02:34.520 --> 00:02:35.423
We'll<00:02:34.666> pull<00:02:34.891> a<00:02:34.907> neighborhood<00:02:35.375> out.

00:02:36.261 --> 00:02:37.034
We're<00:02:36.358> both<00:02:36.599> East<00:02:36.793> Siders.

00:02:37.083 --> 00:02:37.888
How<00:02:37.179> does<00:02:37.324> that<00:02:37.469> work<00:02:37.647> through?

00:02:38.452 --> 00:02:48.030
So<00:02:39.081> that<00:02:39.162> translates<00:02:39.645> to<00:02:39.742> them<00:02:39.983> spending<00:02:40.692> or<00:02:40.773> them<00:02:40.934> getting<00:02:41.095> a<00:02:41.176> bill<00:02:41.514> of<00:02:41.611> about<00:02:42.111> $4,500,<00:02:44.975> which<00:02:45.201> they<00:02:45.541> pay<00:02:45.848> a<00:02:46.252> couple<00:02:46.382> of<00:02:46.414> times<00:02:46.672> a<00:02:46.737> year,<00:02:46.915> both<00:02:47.141> in<00:02:47.222> the<00:02:47.254> summer<00:02:47.545> and<00:02:47.642> in<00:02:47.707> the<00:02:47.788> winter.

00:02:48.677 --> 00:02:48.774
Wow.

00:02:49.356 --> 00:02:51.021
So<00:02:49.663> that's<00:02:50.051> a<00:02:50.148> lot<00:02:50.374> of<00:02:50.455> property<00:02:50.714> tax.

00:02:51.183 --> 00:02:59.362
And<00:02:51.522> that<00:02:51.845> would<00:02:52.153> actually<00:02:52.476> make<00:02:52.670> it<00:02:52.815> difficult<00:02:53.284> for<00:02:53.462> them<00:02:53.704> to<00:02:54.012> even<00:02:54.254> like<00:02:55.079> Feels<00:02:55.304> like<00:02:55.368> it<00:02:55.448> would<00:02:55.544> be<00:02:55.624> difficult<00:02:56.009> for<00:02:56.138> them<00:02:56.266> to<00:02:56.330> even<00:02:56.571> like<00:02:56.747> gain<00:02:57.052> value<00:02:57.630> when<00:02:57.790> you're<00:02:57.935> paying<00:02:58.191> that<00:02:58.352> much<00:02:58.592> overhead<00:02:58.929> in<00:02:58.993> tax.

00:02:59.860 --> 00:03:04.576
Yeah,<00:03:00.582> having<00:03:00.983> high<00:03:01.159> property<00:03:01.560> taxes,<00:03:02.587> you<00:03:02.619> know,<00:03:02.844> inhibits<00:03:03.325> growth<00:03:03.646> in<00:03:03.726> property<00:03:04.127> values.

00:03:04.689 --> 00:03:09.101
It<00:03:04.769> makes<00:03:04.929> it<00:03:05.010> harder<00:03:05.250> to<00:03:05.330> afford<00:03:05.651> living<00:03:05.956> here,<00:03:06.357> harder<00:03:07.256> to<00:03:07.416> build<00:03:07.673> more<00:03:07.962> housing<00:03:08.379> in<00:03:08.459> Detroit.

00:03:10.047 --> 00:03:15.598
Overall,<00:03:10.320> it<00:03:10.384> just<00:03:10.544> makes<00:03:10.769> our<00:03:10.881> city<00:03:11.491> less<00:03:11.667> competitive<00:03:12.534> for<00:03:13.496> folks<00:03:13.673> to<00:03:13.817> move<00:03:13.994> here,<00:03:14.154> but<00:03:14.299> also<00:03:14.491> the<00:03:14.555> people<00:03:14.876> that<00:03:15.037> are<00:03:15.181> already<00:03:15.422> here.

00:03:16.079 --> 00:03:25.923
I<00:03:16.160> think<00:03:16.400> about<00:03:16.705> this<00:03:16.946> because<00:03:17.684> there<00:03:17.860> have<00:03:18.069> been<00:03:18.229> so<00:03:18.486> many<00:03:18.791> calls<00:03:19.432> and<00:03:19.609> discussions<00:03:20.234> about<00:03:20.892> people<00:03:21.212> losing<00:03:21.597> their<00:03:21.757> houses<00:03:22.254> or<00:03:22.478> dealing<00:03:22.814> with<00:03:24.417> issues<00:03:24.897> around<00:03:25.218> displacement.

00:03:26.019 --> 00:03:29.399
And<00:03:26.115> I<00:03:26.243> can't<00:03:26.483> help<00:03:26.644> but<00:03:26.804> think,<00:03:27.365> because<00:03:27.701> Detroit<00:03:28.085> has<00:03:28.262> so<00:03:28.406> much<00:03:28.726> room,<00:03:29.287> right?

00:03:29.463 --> 00:03:33.933
Like<00:03:29.848> where<00:03:30.008> I<00:03:30.088> live<00:03:30.248> on<00:03:30.345> the<00:03:30.489> east<00:03:30.697> side,<00:03:31.290> there's<00:03:31.530> plenty<00:03:31.851> of<00:03:31.883> lots,<00:03:32.411> there's<00:03:32.588> plenty<00:03:32.924> of,<00:03:32.988> plenty<00:03:33.292> of,<00:03:33.373> plenty<00:03:33.629> of<00:03:33.661> lots.

00:03:34.815 --> 00:03:43.803
It's<00:03:34.975> not<00:03:35.455> often<00:03:36.192> about<00:03:36.817> like<00:03:37.170> somebody<00:03:37.554> moving<00:03:37.939> in<00:03:38.035> and<00:03:38.115> pushing<00:03:38.451> somebody<00:03:38.820> out,<00:03:38.916> but<00:03:39.076> that<00:03:39.252> displacement<00:03:39.813> still<00:03:40.054> occurs,<00:03:40.999> but<00:03:41.159> occurs<00:03:41.560> through<00:03:41.720> things<00:03:42.024> like<00:03:42.200> this,<00:03:43.066> through<00:03:43.162> high<00:03:43.322> taxes,<00:03:43.722> right?

00:03:44.187 --> 00:03:44.620
That's<00:03:44.443> right.

00:03:44.668 --> 00:03:48.449
So<00:03:44.908> as<00:03:45.084> people<00:03:45.421> have<00:03:45.565> undoubtedly<00:03:45.981> seen<00:03:46.190> across<00:03:46.446> the<00:03:46.542> city,<00:03:46.847> there's<00:03:47.311> a<00:03:47.407> lot<00:03:47.648> of<00:03:47.728> vacant<00:03:48.048> land.

00:03:48.689 --> 00:04:03.886
My<00:03:48.849> neighborhood<00:03:49.234> on<00:03:49.314> the<00:03:49.394> east<00:03:49.554> side<00:03:49.811> too,<00:03:50.532> My<00:03:50.836> house<00:03:51.013> is<00:03:51.045> surrounded<00:03:51.654> by<00:03:52.119> vacant<00:03:52.375> parcels,<00:03:53.481> and<00:03:53.898> right<00:03:54.123> now,<00:03:54.844> you<00:03:54.876> know,<00:03:54.940> there's<00:03:55.181> a<00:03:55.325> lower<00:03:55.646> incentive<00:03:56.207> to<00:03:56.463> build<00:03:56.768> on<00:03:56.864> those<00:03:57.104> parcels<00:03:57.666> to,<00:03:58.211> you<00:03:58.307> know,<00:03:58.467> make<00:03:58.788> the<00:03:58.868> most<00:03:59.333> use<00:03:59.573> out<00:03:59.670> of<00:03:59.750> property<00:04:00.311> when<00:04:01.176> as<00:04:01.433> soon<00:04:01.609> as<00:04:01.673> you<00:04:01.834> build<00:04:02.058> on<00:04:02.235> it,<00:04:02.395> you<00:04:02.635> just<00:04:02.796> pay<00:04:02.892> more<00:04:03.116> in<00:04:03.196> property<00:04:03.501> taxes.

00:04:04.238 --> 00:04:09.144
And<00:04:04.335> so<00:04:04.463> how<00:04:04.559> does<00:04:04.703> that<00:04:04.960> compare<00:04:05.441> to<00:04:05.826> other<00:04:06.242> major<00:04:07.509> economic<00:04:07.926> centers<00:04:08.727> in<00:04:08.807> the<00:04:08.888> state?

00:04:09.272 --> 00:04:14.595
You<00:04:09.304> know,<00:04:09.914> I've<00:04:10.154> talked<00:04:10.395> to<00:04:10.475> a<00:04:10.491> number<00:04:10.699> of<00:04:10.795> experts<00:04:11.132> who<00:04:11.212> say<00:04:11.373> the<00:04:11.597> economic<00:04:12.030> center<00:04:12.318> of<00:04:12.399> the<00:04:12.431> state's<00:04:12.799> moving<00:04:13.056> west,<00:04:13.312> especially<00:04:13.777> towards<00:04:14.082> Grand<00:04:14.322> Rapids.

00:04:14.964 --> 00:04:15.621
What<00:04:15.044> does<00:04:15.140> that<00:04:15.300> look<00:04:15.461> like?

00:04:15.861 --> 00:04:19.180
Yeah,<00:04:16.519> so<00:04:16.727> Grand<00:04:16.967> Rapids<00:04:17.288> is<00:04:17.384> a<00:04:17.464> good<00:04:18.026> comparison<00:04:18.507> point<00:04:18.731> for<00:04:18.827> Detroit.

00:04:19.244 --> 00:04:23.528
Second<00:04:19.629> biggest<00:04:19.869> city<00:04:20.110> in<00:04:20.190> the<00:04:20.270> state,<00:04:21.072> their<00:04:21.232> property<00:04:21.553> tax<00:04:21.858> rate<00:04:22.115> is<00:04:22.260> half<00:04:22.758> of<00:04:22.902> what<00:04:23.079> ours<00:04:23.384> is.

00:04:23.962 --> 00:04:36.020
And<00:04:24.106> the<00:04:24.186> way<00:04:24.283> they're<00:04:24.524> able<00:04:24.684> to<00:04:24.765> do<00:04:25.005> that<00:04:25.326> is<00:04:25.632> even<00:04:25.792> though<00:04:25.969> Grand<00:04:26.210> Rapids<00:04:27.639> is<00:04:27.815> a<00:04:27.879> third<00:04:28.281> the<00:04:28.361> size<00:04:28.779> of<00:04:28.859> Detroit,<00:04:29.260> both<00:04:29.437> in<00:04:29.501> population<00:04:30.208> and<00:04:30.368> land,<00:04:31.331> their<00:04:31.829> property<00:04:32.231> values<00:04:32.873> that<00:04:33.033> that<00:04:33.355> property<00:04:33.595> tax<00:04:33.836> rate<00:04:34.013> is<00:04:34.093> applied<00:04:34.478> to<00:04:34.880> is<00:04:34.976> about<00:04:35.201> the<00:04:35.281> same<00:04:35.586> as<00:04:35.683> Detroit.

00:04:36.084 --> 00:04:40.243
So<00:04:36.245> they're<00:04:36.325> getting<00:04:36.582> as<00:04:36.726> much<00:04:37.031> revenue<00:04:37.609> as<00:04:37.834> we<00:04:37.995> are<00:04:39.279> at<00:04:39.376> half<00:04:39.697> the<00:04:39.777> tax<00:04:40.098> rate.

00:04:40.724 --> 00:04:40.821
Whoa.

00:04:41.527 --> 00:04:41.656
Wow.

00:04:42.346 --> 00:04:46.553
And<00:04:42.426> so<00:04:42.587> do<00:04:42.731> these<00:04:42.892> high<00:04:43.068> tax<00:04:43.390> rates<00:04:44.112> help<00:04:44.497> keep<00:04:44.819> the<00:04:44.915> land<00:04:45.220> values<00:04:45.718> low<00:04:45.878> in<00:04:45.959> Detroit<00:04:46.296> as<00:04:46.440> well?

00:04:47.146 --> 00:04:58.399
Yeah,<00:04:47.707> both<00:04:48.140> the<00:04:48.445> higher<00:04:48.685> property<00:04:49.006> tax<00:04:49.310> rate<00:04:50.368> serves<00:04:50.849> to<00:04:51.090> devalue<00:04:51.651> property<00:04:52.693> and<00:04:52.837> also<00:04:53.173> it's<00:04:53.334> just<00:04:53.574> led<00:04:53.799> to<00:04:53.959> this<00:04:54.215> glut<00:04:54.520> of<00:04:54.696> vacant<00:04:55.001> land,<00:04:55.963> which<00:04:56.203> then,<00:04:56.684> you<00:04:56.780> know,<00:04:56.860> makes<00:04:57.101> it<00:04:57.181> worth<00:04:57.806> a<00:04:57.822> lower<00:04:58.063> amount.

00:04:58.560 --> 00:05:01.958
If<00:04:58.688> we<00:04:58.768> have<00:04:58.880> a<00:04:58.928> huge<00:04:59.329> oversupply<00:04:59.970> of<00:05:00.131> vacant<00:05:00.387> land,<00:05:00.948> it's<00:05:01.108> not<00:05:01.205> going<00:05:01.333> to<00:05:01.365> be<00:05:01.493> worth<00:05:01.685> as<00:05:01.814> much.

00:05:02.647 --> 00:05:04.122
So<00:05:03.112> what<00:05:03.272> can<00:05:03.433> we<00:05:03.593> do,<00:05:03.994> right?

00:05:04.186 --> 00:05:08.049
Because<00:05:04.555> at<00:05:04.699> the<00:05:04.859> end<00:05:04.956> of<00:05:05.020> the<00:05:05.116> day,<00:05:06.334> it<00:05:06.398> needs<00:05:06.719> to<00:05:06.799> be<00:05:07.024> turned<00:05:07.296> into<00:05:07.520> policy.

00:05:08.162 --> 00:05:11.448
So<00:05:08.306> what<00:05:08.402> are<00:05:08.482> some<00:05:08.659> ideas<00:05:09.204> that<00:05:09.428> you<00:05:09.588> have<00:05:09.925> that<00:05:10.165> we<00:05:10.310> can<00:05:10.406> kind<00:05:10.566> of<00:05:10.630> walk<00:05:10.823> through<00:05:10.967> a<00:05:10.983> little<00:05:11.191> bit?

00:05:11.672 --> 00:05:11.929
Yeah.

00:05:12.169 --> 00:05:16.032
So<00:05:12.249> when<00:05:12.346> you<00:05:12.474> look<00:05:12.714> at<00:05:13.131> the<00:05:13.211> property<00:05:13.452> tax<00:05:13.692> rate<00:05:13.836> in<00:05:13.933> Detroit,<00:05:14.494> two<00:05:14.894> big<00:05:15.135> things<00:05:15.391> stand<00:05:15.792> out.

00:05:16.097 --> 00:05:31.325
Like<00:05:16.257> I<00:05:16.273> said<00:05:16.481> earlier,<00:05:17.363> the<00:05:17.700> property<00:05:18.020> taxes<00:05:18.726> include<00:05:18.982> the<00:05:19.046> city,<00:05:19.463> the<00:05:19.559> schools,<00:05:20.088> the<00:05:20.168> county,<00:05:20.665> the<00:05:20.745> library,<00:05:21.707> but<00:05:21.867> the<00:05:21.948> city's<00:05:22.653> operating<00:05:23.134> millage,<00:05:23.631> which<00:05:23.871> is<00:05:24.272> 20<00:05:24.512> mills,<00:05:25.458> and<00:05:25.618> the<00:05:25.699> school<00:05:26.196> debt<00:05:26.500> millage,<00:05:26.901> which<00:05:27.013> is<00:05:27.157> 13<00:05:27.558> mills,<00:05:28.023> are<00:05:28.263> unusually<00:05:28.760> high,<00:05:29.081> especially<00:05:29.482> for<00:05:29.802> a<00:05:29.818> city<00:05:30.123> that<00:05:30.283> also<00:05:30.460> has<00:05:30.604> an<00:05:30.684> income<00:05:30.924> tax.

00:05:31.950 --> 00:05:42.210
And<00:05:32.047> so<00:05:32.608> those<00:05:33.089> are<00:05:33.233> two<00:05:33.489> areas<00:05:33.954> where<00:05:35.012> if<00:05:35.156> we<00:05:35.317> could<00:05:35.557> replace<00:05:36.038> those<00:05:36.279> revenues<00:05:36.695> with<00:05:36.775> something<00:05:37.321> else,<00:05:37.898> we<00:05:38.058> could<00:05:38.523> actually<00:05:39.180> either<00:05:39.404> reduce<00:05:39.741> or<00:05:39.837> eliminate<00:05:40.527> those<00:05:41.264> taxes<00:05:41.745> over<00:05:41.905> time.

00:05:42.771 --> 00:05:46.842
Right<00:05:42.931> now,<00:05:43.749> we've,<00:05:44.213> you<00:05:44.310> know,<00:05:44.791> new<00:05:45.031> leaders<00:05:45.352> take<00:05:45.913> their<00:05:46.057> seats<00:05:46.313> in<00:05:46.394> Lansing.

00:05:46.955 --> 00:05:51.363
It'll<00:05:47.179> be<00:05:47.275> a<00:05:47.419> great<00:05:47.596> time<00:05:47.997> to<00:05:48.093> start<00:05:48.381> having<00:05:48.702> this<00:05:48.798> debate<00:05:49.263> about<00:05:49.584> replacement<00:05:50.145> revenues<00:05:50.481> for<00:05:50.545> the<00:05:50.610> for<00:05:50.658> the<00:05:50.690> city<00:05:50.818> of<00:05:50.882> Detroit.

00:05:51.828 --> 00:05:59.860
3<00:05:52.149> ideas<00:05:53.046> that<00:05:53.207> come<00:05:53.351> to<00:05:53.383> mind<00:05:53.608> that<00:05:53.752> might<00:05:53.848> be<00:05:54.008> a<00:05:54.089> really<00:05:54.329> good<00:05:54.505> fit<00:05:54.730> for<00:05:54.874> Detroit,<00:05:55.451> and<00:05:55.531> these<00:05:55.756> aren't<00:05:55.916> all<00:05:56.012> new<00:05:56.317> ideas,<00:05:57.439> are<00:05:58.401> one,<00:05:58.738> an<00:05:58.898> entertainment<00:05:59.379> tax.

00:06:00.566 --> 00:06:03.532
This<00:06:00.886> has<00:06:00.982> been<00:06:01.223> talked<00:06:01.479> about<00:06:01.688> quite<00:06:01.880> a<00:06:02.008> bit<00:06:02.265> over<00:06:02.425> the<00:06:02.505> past<00:06:02.922> year<00:06:03.067> and<00:06:03.163> a<00:06:03.227> half.

00:06:04.029 --> 00:06:18.810
The<00:06:04.109> Citizens<00:06:04.493> Research<00:06:04.814> Council<00:06:05.087> of<00:06:05.151> Michigan<00:06:05.552> did<00:06:05.728> a<00:06:05.792> study<00:06:06.594> for<00:06:06.786> the<00:06:06.834> city<00:06:07.075> of<00:06:07.235> Detroit<00:06:08.117> over<00:06:08.277> a<00:06:08.421> year<00:06:08.582> ago<00:06:08.838> that<00:06:08.999> estimated<00:06:09.463> that<00:06:09.800> a<00:06:09.960> 10%<00:06:10.602> tax<00:06:11.884> on<00:06:12.029> the<00:06:12.269> ticket<00:06:12.590> price<00:06:12.926> for<00:06:13.071> major<00:06:13.552> events,<00:06:13.808> so<00:06:13.904> this<00:06:14.113> would<00:06:14.209> be<00:06:14.369> like<00:06:14.546> Detroit<00:06:14.850> Lions<00:06:15.251> games<00:06:15.957> or<00:06:16.614> major<00:06:16.999> headliner<00:06:17.496> concerts<00:06:18.057> downtown.

00:06:19.003 --> 00:06:24.339
So<00:06:19.083> we're<00:06:19.195> not<00:06:19.419> talking<00:06:19.740> like,<00:06:20.061> um,<00:06:20.993> like<00:06:21.620> Wayne<00:06:21.942> State<00:06:22.939> theater<00:06:23.567> plays<00:06:23.969> or<00:06:24.065> something.

00:06:24.435 --> 00:06:27.652
We're<00:06:24.532> talking<00:06:25.320> Tigers<00:06:25.738> games,<00:06:26.221> Rolling<00:06:26.559> Stones,<00:06:27.105> that<00:06:27.202> kind<00:06:27.411> of<00:06:27.459> stuff.

00:06:27.733 --> 00:06:27.974
Correct.

00:06:28.071 --> 00:06:31.525
Yeah,<00:06:28.167> no<00:06:28.376> one's<00:06:28.537> going<00:06:28.634> to<00:06:28.714> be<00:06:28.794> collecting<00:06:29.422> a<00:06:29.502> tax<00:06:29.904> on<00:06:30.001> the<00:06:30.130> COVID<00:06:30.310> charge<00:06:30.803> at<00:06:30.967> the<00:06:31.066> old<00:06:31.148> Miami.

00:06:33.789 --> 00:06:34.934
That<00:06:34.031> would<00:06:34.128> be<00:06:34.289> hilarious.

00:06:35.241 --> 00:06:37.580
I'm<00:06:35.499> not<00:06:35.677> for<00:06:35.983> this,<00:06:36.548> but<00:06:36.693> it<00:06:36.725> makes<00:06:36.951> me<00:06:37.032> laugh<00:06:37.274> inside.

00:06:38.064 --> 00:06:45.145
And<00:06:38.161> so<00:06:38.548> at<00:06:38.629> a<00:06:38.710> 10%<00:06:39.129> tax<00:06:39.452> rate,<00:06:39.597> that<00:06:39.710> would<00:06:39.839> raise<00:06:40.097> $50<00:06:40.339> million,<00:06:41.452> and<00:06:41.549> that<00:06:41.791> could,<00:06:42.582> that<00:06:42.678> could<00:06:42.791> let<00:06:43.082> us<00:06:43.326> cut<00:06:43.569> $5<00:06:43.959> mil<00:06:44.203> from<00:06:44.365> the<00:06:44.398> property<00:06:44.706> tax<00:06:45.031> bill.

00:06:45.827 --> 00:06:52.507
Other<00:06:46.005> cities<00:06:46.493> like<00:06:46.639> Columbus,<00:06:47.045> Ohio,<00:06:47.646> Cincinnati,<00:06:48.523> Cleveland,<00:06:49.400> um,<00:06:50.086> other<00:06:50.423> states<00:06:50.679> across<00:06:50.984> the<00:06:51.064> country,<00:06:51.385> they,<00:06:51.561> they<00:06:51.689> have<00:06:51.946> this<00:06:52.170> tax.

00:06:52.747 --> 00:06:54.559
Detroit's<00:06:53.148> an<00:06:53.292> outlier<00:06:53.629> for<00:06:53.773> not<00:06:54.094> having<00:06:54.414> one.

00:06:54.992 --> 00:07:07.865
It's<00:06:55.152> a<00:06:55.232> way<00:06:55.392> for<00:06:55.697> us<00:06:55.937> to<00:06:56.034> shift<00:06:56.290> some<00:06:56.450> of<00:06:56.515> the<00:06:56.595> tax<00:06:56.915> burden<00:06:57.220> to<00:06:57.396> visitors,<00:06:58.358> both<00:06:58.599> from<00:06:58.759> within<00:06:58.999> the<00:06:59.064> state<00:06:59.384> and<00:06:59.464> from<00:06:59.625> outside<00:06:59.961> the<00:07:00.041> state,<00:07:00.763> and<00:07:00.843> really<00:07:01.164> takes<00:07:01.420> advantage<00:07:01.821> of—<00:07:01.949> we've<00:07:02.109> invested<00:07:02.590> a<00:07:02.606> lot<00:07:02.943> of<00:07:03.087> money<00:07:03.632> in<00:07:03.681> our<00:07:03.985> sports<00:07:04.290> and<00:07:04.354> entertainment<00:07:04.851> district<00:07:05.316> with<00:07:05.572> Little<00:07:05.733> Caesars<00:07:06.069> Arena,<00:07:06.935> all<00:07:07.015> the<00:07:07.095> concert<00:07:07.480> venues.

00:07:08.538 --> 00:07:12.594
This<00:07:08.698> tax<00:07:09.083> would<00:07:09.259> let<00:07:09.484> us<00:07:09.804> get<00:07:10.045> a<00:07:10.141> little<00:07:10.382> bit<00:07:10.478> of<00:07:10.622> extra<00:07:10.943> public<00:07:11.327> revenue<00:07:11.744> out<00:07:11.840> of<00:07:11.969> those<00:07:12.145> investments.

00:07:13.572 --> 00:07:21.892
There's<00:07:13.812> also<00:07:14.069> this<00:07:14.630> thing,<00:07:14.950> you<00:07:15.031> know,<00:07:15.592> Gambling<00:07:16.329> is<00:07:16.409> a<00:07:16.473> big<00:07:16.634> thing<00:07:16.874> in<00:07:16.954> this<00:07:17.034> state,<00:07:18.301> and<00:07:18.557> Detroit<00:07:18.958> has<00:07:19.102> been<00:07:19.199> a<00:07:19.279> big<00:07:19.503> part<00:07:19.904> of<00:07:20.016> that<00:07:20.224> revenue<00:07:20.625> pie<00:07:20.882> for<00:07:21.122> a<00:07:21.202> long<00:07:21.507> time.

00:07:22.228 --> 00:07:32.311
Yeah,<00:07:22.405> so<00:07:22.725> wagering<00:07:23.126> taxes<00:07:23.591> for<00:07:23.639> the<00:07:23.703> city<00:07:23.911> of<00:07:23.992> Detroit,<00:07:24.489> the<00:07:24.569> taxes<00:07:24.953> we<00:07:25.050> get<00:07:25.691> from<00:07:25.851> the<00:07:25.995> 3<00:07:26.172> casinos<00:07:26.669> that<00:07:26.797> are<00:07:26.893> located<00:07:27.374> here,<00:07:28.240> has<00:07:28.576> risen<00:07:28.977> to<00:07:29.137> being<00:07:29.538> the<00:07:29.618> city's<00:07:30.099> second<00:07:30.500> biggest<00:07:30.740> revenue<00:07:30.997> source,<00:07:31.382> over<00:07:31.542> $300<00:07:32.023> million.

00:07:33.225 --> 00:07:39.685
And<00:07:33.369> that's<00:07:33.930> due<00:07:34.091> in<00:07:34.171> large<00:07:34.492> part<00:07:34.748> to<00:07:35.069> a<00:07:35.149> few<00:07:35.309> years<00:07:35.550> ago,<00:07:36.127> the<00:07:36.287> state<00:07:36.511> of<00:07:36.543> Michigan<00:07:37.169> legalized<00:07:37.778> internet<00:07:38.114> gaming<00:07:38.740> and<00:07:39.012> sports<00:07:39.397> betting.

00:07:40.423 --> 00:07:44.706
It's<00:07:40.743> authorized<00:07:41.304> for<00:07:41.401> both<00:07:41.641> the<00:07:41.962> Detroit's<00:07:42.283> 3<00:07:42.443> casinos<00:07:42.860> as<00:07:42.989> well<00:07:43.101> as<00:07:43.229> the<00:07:43.310> tribal<00:07:43.631> casinos<00:07:43.967> across<00:07:44.288> the<00:07:44.369> state.

00:07:45.315 --> 00:07:47.947
And,<00:07:45.572> and<00:07:45.716> that's<00:07:45.893> been<00:07:46.037> a<00:07:46.053> huge<00:07:46.599> revenue<00:07:47.161> boost<00:07:47.481> for<00:07:47.578> the<00:07:47.658> city.

00:07:48.605 --> 00:07:59.580
Um,<00:07:48.861> that<00:07:49.118> said,<00:07:50.049> uh,<00:07:50.209> when<00:07:50.370> this<00:07:50.466> legislation<00:07:50.947> was<00:07:51.092> passed<00:07:51.348> back<00:07:51.589> in<00:07:51.653> 2019,<00:07:53.097> part<00:07:53.210> of<00:07:53.338> the<00:07:53.418> legislative<00:07:53.916> deal-making<00:07:54.638> was<00:07:54.878> that<00:07:55.119> Detroit<00:07:55.520> would<00:07:55.665> only<00:07:55.841> get<00:07:56.162> 30%<00:07:56.868> of<00:07:56.964> the<00:07:57.109> revenue<00:07:57.750> that<00:07:57.991> comes<00:07:58.312> from<00:07:58.633> our<00:07:58.874> casinos.

00:08:00.157 --> 00:08:09.945
Before<00:08:00.510> that,<00:08:00.976> when,<00:08:01.441> uh,<00:08:01.762> voters<00:08:02.259> in<00:08:02.404> Michigan<00:08:02.805> authorized<00:08:03.623> gambling<00:08:04.185> generally,<00:08:04.746> um,<00:08:05.308> back<00:08:05.564> in<00:08:05.629> the<00:08:05.709> late<00:08:05.869> '90s,<00:08:07.137> they<00:08:07.313> all<00:08:07.474> said<00:08:07.795> that<00:08:07.955> Detroit<00:08:08.340> should<00:08:08.421> get<00:08:08.517> 55%<00:08:09.399> of<00:08:09.464> the<00:08:09.544> revenue.

00:08:10.538 --> 00:08:27.201
So<00:08:10.699> if<00:08:10.827> Detroit<00:08:11.228> actually<00:08:11.404> got<00:08:11.629> that<00:08:11.805> same<00:08:12.126> 55%<00:08:12.687> on<00:08:13.249> internet<00:08:13.553> gaming,<00:08:14.275> that<00:08:14.371> would<00:08:14.451> be<00:08:14.532> an<00:08:14.628> extra<00:08:14.836> $120<00:08:15.734> million<00:08:16.857> for<00:08:17.017> Detroit,<00:08:18.060> which<00:08:18.220> we<00:08:18.364> could<00:08:18.541> use<00:08:18.942> specifically<00:08:20.145> to<00:08:20.225> help<00:08:20.545> pay<00:08:20.850> off<00:08:21.107> Detroit<00:08:21.347> Public<00:08:21.588> Schools<00:08:22.470> facilities<00:08:23.192> debt<00:08:23.737> a<00:08:23.977> lot<00:08:24.170> sooner<00:08:24.619> than<00:08:24.875> 2040<00:08:25.581> when<00:08:25.677> it's<00:08:25.822> currently<00:08:26.094> scheduled<00:08:26.543> to<00:08:26.575> be<00:08:26.704> paid<00:08:26.944> off.

00:08:27.602 --> 00:08:31.242
If<00:08:27.762> that<00:08:28.003> were<00:08:28.083> to<00:08:28.163> happen,<00:08:28.548> we<00:08:28.644> could<00:08:28.869> eliminate<00:08:29.446> $13<00:08:29.927> mils<00:08:30.312> from<00:08:30.408> the<00:08:30.504> property<00:08:30.809> tax<00:08:31.130> bill.

00:08:31.852 --> 00:08:34.626
Wow,<00:08:32.092> that's<00:08:33.135> making<00:08:33.423> a<00:08:33.439> lot<00:08:33.552> of<00:08:33.616> progress<00:08:34.097> very<00:08:34.321> quickly.

00:08:35.139 --> 00:08:41.734
And<00:08:35.219> as<00:08:35.300> you<00:08:35.380> can<00:08:35.540> see,<00:08:36.487> You<00:08:36.583> know,<00:08:37.064> people<00:08:37.305> should<00:08:37.449> understand<00:08:38.011> that<00:08:38.172> there's<00:08:38.348> no<00:08:38.653> one<00:08:38.910> silver<00:08:39.311> bullet<00:08:39.568> solution<00:08:40.113> to<00:08:40.274> property<00:08:40.595> tax<00:08:40.835> reform<00:08:41.237> in<00:08:41.317> Detroit.

00:08:41.814 --> 00:08:50.480
It's<00:08:41.959> going<00:08:42.135> to<00:08:42.183> take<00:08:42.601> multiple<00:08:43.243> answers<00:08:43.885> that<00:08:44.029> have<00:08:44.446> multiple<00:08:45.233> different<00:08:45.650> varied<00:08:45.971> impacts<00:08:47.014> in<00:08:47.094> order<00:08:47.255> to<00:08:47.415> get<00:08:47.720> all<00:08:47.752> the<00:08:47.832> way<00:08:47.961> across<00:08:48.217> the<00:08:48.314> finish<00:08:48.522> line,<00:08:48.619> to<00:08:48.683> have<00:08:48.843> transformational<00:08:49.822> tax<00:08:50.127> reform.

00:08:50.705 --> 00:08:56.530
Well,<00:08:51.010> what<00:08:51.170> I've<00:08:51.347> learned<00:08:51.668> after<00:08:51.973> doing<00:08:52.310> nearly<00:08:52.615> 2,000<00:08:53.096> episodes<00:08:53.513> of<00:08:53.593> this<00:08:53.690> show<00:08:54.075> is<00:08:54.219> that<00:08:54.396> there<00:08:54.556> is<00:08:54.717> no<00:08:54.893> silver<00:08:55.278> bullet<00:08:55.535> solution<00:08:56.001> for<00:08:56.241> anything.

00:08:57.349 --> 00:09:02.692
It<00:08:57.429> seems<00:08:57.926> it's<00:08:58.311> always<00:08:58.488> kind<00:08:58.665> of<00:08:58.793> like<00:08:59.355> we<00:08:59.435> got<00:08:59.515> to<00:08:59.611> do<00:08:59.692> a<00:08:59.708> little<00:08:59.932> here,<00:09:00.253> we<00:09:00.333> got<00:09:00.494> to<00:09:00.638> do<00:09:00.735> a<00:09:00.815> little<00:09:01.056> there,<00:09:01.441> we<00:09:01.537> got<00:09:01.698> to<00:09:01.842> do<00:09:01.954> a<00:09:02.002> little<00:09:02.259> over<00:09:02.484> here.

00:09:03.479 --> 00:09:03.639
So,.

00:09:04.265 --> 00:09:09.221
And<00:09:04.345> so,<00:09:04.585> and<00:09:04.666> so<00:09:04.810> the<00:09:04.987> third<00:09:05.211> idea,<00:09:05.949> it's<00:09:06.029> an<00:09:06.254> oldie<00:09:06.671> but<00:09:06.767> a<00:09:06.895> goodie,<00:09:07.697> is<00:09:08.419> the<00:09:08.500> land<00:09:08.708> value<00:09:08.997> tax.

00:09:09.382 --> 00:09:10.809
Oh,<00:09:09.703> we're<00:09:09.799> bringing<00:09:10.104> back<00:09:10.344> the<00:09:10.441> hits.

00:09:11.243 --> 00:09:17.675
I'm<00:09:11.788> just<00:09:11.964> laughing<00:09:12.173> because<00:09:12.510> years<00:09:12.783> ago<00:09:13.328> we<00:09:13.488> were<00:09:13.585> cited<00:09:14.050> in<00:09:14.130> a<00:09:14.146> city<00:09:14.355> council<00:09:14.675> report<00:09:15.397> talking<00:09:15.798> about<00:09:16.215> land<00:09:16.376> value<00:09:16.697> tax,<00:09:17.098> LVT.

00:09:18.285 --> 00:09:19.953
Very<00:09:18.541> interesting<00:09:18.942> to<00:09:19.023> bring<00:09:19.183> that<00:09:19.263> back<00:09:19.520> on<00:09:19.648> the<00:09:19.728> table.

00:09:20.290 --> 00:09:24.156
And,<00:09:20.546> and<00:09:20.691> I<00:09:20.787> know<00:09:21.653> this<00:09:21.910> didn't<00:09:22.070> get<00:09:22.215> across<00:09:22.536> the<00:09:22.616> finish<00:09:22.872> line<00:09:23.434> 3<00:09:23.674> years<00:09:23.915> ago.

00:09:24.236 --> 00:09:26.835
It<00:09:24.300> stalled<00:09:24.701> out<00:09:24.733> in<00:09:24.878> Lansing,<00:09:25.824> but<00:09:25.872> it's<00:09:25.984> still<00:09:26.177> a<00:09:26.305> really<00:09:26.482> good<00:09:26.642> idea.

00:09:26.883 --> 00:09:30.059
And<00:09:27.027> the<00:09:27.123> reason<00:09:27.444> why<00:09:27.909> is<00:09:28.567> what<00:09:28.679> does<00:09:28.808> Detroit<00:09:29.209> have<00:09:29.513> a<00:09:29.610> lot<00:09:29.915> of?

00:09:30.332 --> 00:09:32.657
Land,<00:09:30.973> and<00:09:31.358> land<00:09:31.614> can't<00:09:31.935> go<00:09:32.095> anywhere.

00:09:33.362 --> 00:09:44.763
So<00:09:33.522> if<00:09:33.603> you<00:09:33.699> were<00:09:33.843> to<00:09:33.939> shift<00:09:34.565> the<00:09:34.597> tax<00:09:34.982> burden<00:09:35.302> from<00:09:35.928> houses,<00:09:36.409> from<00:09:36.745> buildings<00:09:37.451> onto<00:09:37.788> just<00:09:38.108> the<00:09:38.253> land,<00:09:39.215> you<00:09:39.247> shift<00:09:39.536> the<00:09:39.632> tax<00:09:39.952> burden<00:09:40.353> from<00:09:40.674> homeowners<00:09:41.700> to<00:09:41.973> speculators<00:09:42.839> and<00:09:42.935> scrapyards<00:09:43.721> and<00:09:43.881> surface<00:09:44.346> lots.

00:09:45.228 --> 00:09:57.799
And<00:09:45.725> we<00:09:45.885> could<00:09:46.110> make<00:09:46.511> up<00:09:46.863> some<00:09:47.024> of<00:09:47.104> the<00:09:47.232> revenue<00:09:47.633> from<00:09:47.890> reducing<00:09:48.691> the<00:09:48.836> operating<00:09:49.333> millage<00:09:50.375> that<00:09:50.760> hits<00:09:51.642> everyone<00:09:51.979> right<00:09:52.139> now<00:09:53.165> and<00:09:53.662> provide<00:09:54.047> relief<00:09:54.464> to<00:09:55.089> homeowners<00:09:55.891> and<00:09:56.067> to<00:09:56.164> support<00:09:56.949> building<00:09:57.270> more<00:09:57.494> housing.

00:09:58.216 --> 00:10:06.302
Now<00:09:59.195> that<00:09:59.740> change<00:10:00.093> in<00:10:00.222> tax<00:10:00.559> might<00:10:00.783> also<00:10:01.762> incentivize<00:10:02.628> speculators<00:10:03.350> to<00:10:03.463> not<00:10:03.687> hold<00:10:03.912> on<00:10:04.040> to<00:10:04.168> land<00:10:04.425> for<00:10:04.570> so<00:10:04.666> long,<00:10:04.794> because<00:10:05.003> that's<00:10:05.195> one<00:10:05.308> thing<00:10:05.452> I<00:10:05.516> hear<00:10:05.677> from<00:10:05.773> a<00:10:05.821> lot<00:10:05.997> of<00:10:06.030> people.

00:10:06.479 --> 00:10:16.041
There'll<00:10:07.056> be<00:10:07.233> a<00:10:07.361> key<00:10:07.618> piece<00:10:07.939> of<00:10:08.019> land,<00:10:08.340> or<00:10:08.404> there'll<00:10:08.661> be<00:10:08.741> some<00:10:08.998> sort<00:10:09.238> of<00:10:09.367> block<00:10:09.639> that<00:10:09.720> they'll<00:10:10.025> need<00:10:10.746> to<00:10:10.827> get<00:10:11.003> something<00:10:11.388> done,<00:10:12.174> and<00:10:12.656> you've<00:10:12.768> got<00:10:12.912> a<00:10:12.993> bunch<00:10:13.233> of<00:10:13.265> people<00:10:13.795> who<00:10:14.019> hold<00:10:14.212> these<00:10:14.677> basically<00:10:15.303> lottery<00:10:15.640> tickets.

00:10:16.426 --> 00:10:17.886
They<00:10:16.506> don't<00:10:16.683> live<00:10:16.907> here<00:10:17.164> for<00:10:17.308> the<00:10:17.389> most<00:10:17.645> part.

00:10:18.207 --> 00:10:23.389
They're—<00:10:18.688> some<00:10:18.865> of<00:10:18.929> them—<00:10:19.170> heck,<00:10:19.394> when<00:10:19.490> I<00:10:19.651> lived<00:10:19.827> in<00:10:19.875> North<00:10:20.132> Corktown,<00:10:20.517> there<00:10:20.597> was<00:10:20.710> a<00:10:20.774> guy<00:10:21.015> living<00:10:21.255> in<00:10:21.400> China<00:10:22.442> that<00:10:22.523> held<00:10:22.715> a<00:10:22.779> bunch<00:10:23.020> of<00:10:23.052> land.

00:10:23.902 --> 00:10:31.112
And<00:10:24.046> it's<00:10:24.447> a<00:10:24.607> rounding<00:10:25.008> error<00:10:25.184> for<00:10:25.344> them,<00:10:25.584> but<00:10:25.745> it's—<00:10:26.145> it<00:10:26.369> really,<00:10:26.706> like,<00:10:26.882> screws<00:10:27.331> up<00:10:27.443> an<00:10:27.523> entire<00:10:28.068> neighborhood<00:10:29.029> due<00:10:29.173> to<00:10:29.253> some,<00:10:29.814> some<00:10:30.215> dude<00:10:30.471> somewhere.

00:10:31.593 --> 00:10:32.362
No,<00:10:31.705> that's<00:10:31.897> absolutely<00:10:32.153> right.

00:10:32.458 --> 00:10:45.260
I<00:10:32.474> mean,<00:10:32.714> we've<00:10:32.810> seen<00:10:33.019> that<00:10:33.099> with<00:10:33.211> a<00:10:33.339> lot<00:10:33.531> of<00:10:33.611> major<00:10:34.957> development<00:10:35.358> projects<00:10:35.758> in<00:10:35.838> Detroit<00:10:36.159> where<00:10:36.319> there's<00:10:36.543> that<00:10:36.784> one<00:10:36.960> parcel<00:10:37.441> that,<00:10:37.761> that<00:10:38.001> is<00:10:38.162> needed<00:10:39.043> and<00:10:39.123> that<00:10:39.508> owner<00:10:39.764> can<00:10:40.181> sit<00:10:40.469> on<00:10:40.629> it<00:10:40.789> and<00:10:40.982> sell<00:10:41.222> it<00:10:41.366> for<00:10:42.247> a<00:10:42.327> hefty<00:10:42.632> ransom<00:10:43.689> because<00:10:44.026> it's<00:10:44.170> that<00:10:44.330> last<00:10:44.651> piece<00:10:44.827> of<00:10:44.907> the<00:10:45.035> puzzle.

00:10:46.157 --> 00:10:52.181
With<00:10:46.253> something<00:10:46.493> like<00:10:46.653> a<00:10:46.669> land<00:10:46.894> value<00:10:47.134> tax,<00:10:47.599> it<00:10:47.855> can<00:10:47.999> give<00:10:48.111> an<00:10:48.240> incentive<00:10:48.800> to<00:10:49.377> do<00:10:49.457> something<00:10:49.938> more<00:10:50.162> productive<00:10:50.643> with<00:10:50.803> the<00:10:50.899> land<00:10:51.236> other<00:10:51.380> than<00:10:51.556> sit<00:10:51.845> on<00:10:52.021> it.

00:10:52.646 --> 00:10:57.682
And<00:10:52.742> if<00:10:52.886> we<00:10:52.983> were<00:10:53.079> to<00:10:53.528> create<00:10:53.785> a<00:10:53.849> land<00:10:54.025> value<00:10:54.346> tax,<00:10:54.667> we<00:10:54.747> could<00:10:54.891> raise<00:10:55.693> as<00:10:55.853> much<00:10:56.094> as<00:10:56.655> another<00:10:56.832> $130<00:10:57.457> million.

00:10:58.355 --> 00:11:07.753
And<00:10:58.451> so<00:10:58.660> as<00:10:58.756> I<00:10:58.772> said<00:10:59.013> earlier,<00:10:59.237> $50<00:10:59.526> million<00:10:59.959> from<00:11:00.119> an<00:11:00.199> entertainment<00:11:00.680> tax,<00:11:01.306> $120<00:11:01.835> million<00:11:02.509> from<00:11:02.829> getting<00:11:03.070> our<00:11:03.166> fair<00:11:03.407> share<00:11:03.792> of<00:11:04.369> internet<00:11:04.674> gaming<00:11:04.930> taxes,<00:11:05.812> and<00:11:05.893> $130<00:11:06.374> million<00:11:06.919> from<00:11:07.079> a<00:11:07.095> land<00:11:07.256> value<00:11:07.496> tax.

00:11:07.817 --> 00:11:12.997
That<00:11:08.041> adds<00:11:08.154> up<00:11:08.282> to<00:11:08.378> the<00:11:08.458> $300<00:11:08.859> million<00:11:09.501> we'd<00:11:09.725> need<00:11:10.447> to<00:11:11.024> reduce<00:11:11.345> property<00:11:11.666> taxes<00:11:12.067> by<00:11:12.227> 33<00:11:12.644> mills.

00:11:13.109 --> 00:11:18.289
We<00:11:13.189> could<00:11:13.430> eliminate<00:11:13.847> the<00:11:13.927> city<00:11:14.216> operating<00:11:14.633> millage<00:11:15.178> and<00:11:15.435> the<00:11:15.499> school<00:11:15.755> debt<00:11:15.916> millage<00:11:16.653> sometime<00:11:17.054> in<00:11:17.263> the<00:11:17.295> next<00:11:17.680> 6<00:11:17.984> years.

00:11:19.123 --> 00:11:21.976
That<00:11:19.524> is<00:11:19.684> transformative<00:11:20.469> change,<00:11:21.207> but<00:11:21.303> I<00:11:21.367> have<00:11:21.527> questions.

00:11:22.185 --> 00:11:24.781
Okay,<00:11:23.050> first<00:11:23.371> off,<00:11:23.996> land<00:11:24.252> value<00:11:24.573> tax.

00:11:24.829 --> 00:11:26.224
We're<00:11:24.910> talking<00:11:25.134> about<00:11:25.375> raising<00:11:25.711> a<00:11:25.775> bunch<00:11:26.016> of<00:11:26.048> money.

00:11:26.737 --> 00:11:29.655
My<00:11:26.897> first<00:11:27.458> worry<00:11:28.084> is<00:11:28.805> homeowners,<00:11:29.462> right?

00:11:29.927 --> 00:11:35.986
Because<00:11:30.328> we<00:11:30.424> don't<00:11:30.664> want<00:11:30.809> to<00:11:30.905> do<00:11:31.049> anything,<00:11:31.610> at<00:11:31.642> least<00:11:31.867> in<00:11:31.947> my<00:11:32.123> mind,<00:11:32.989> that<00:11:33.149> punishes<00:11:33.694> people<00:11:34.015> who<00:11:34.111> have<00:11:34.255> been<00:11:34.416> sticking<00:11:34.816> it<00:11:34.896> out<00:11:35.153> or<00:11:35.233> doing<00:11:35.634> things<00:11:35.874> here.

00:11:36.435 --> 00:11:39.032
And<00:11:36.515> I<00:11:36.580> think<00:11:36.740> part<00:11:36.916> of<00:11:36.980> this<00:11:37.157> is<00:11:37.317> that,<00:11:37.638> like,<00:11:37.782> affordability<00:11:38.535> agenda,<00:11:38.904> right?

00:11:39.144 --> 00:11:43.585
So,<00:11:39.241> like,<00:11:39.946> if<00:11:40.122> it<00:11:40.523> doesn't<00:11:40.844> help<00:11:41.148> homeowners,<00:11:41.725> then<00:11:42.767> what<00:11:42.928> is<00:11:43.088> the<00:11:43.168> benefit?

00:11:43.633 --> 00:11:44.899
So<00:11:43.681> let's<00:11:43.841> talk<00:11:43.905> about—<00:11:44.130> does<00:11:44.226> it<00:11:44.354> help<00:11:44.531> homeowners?

00:11:45.156 --> 00:11:55.265
Yeah,<00:11:45.653> and<00:11:45.733> this<00:11:45.877> was<00:11:46.037> a<00:11:46.069> big<00:11:46.278> part<00:11:46.534> of<00:11:46.631> the<00:11:46.759> discussion<00:11:47.192> a<00:11:47.256> few<00:11:47.480> years<00:11:47.721> ago,<00:11:48.458> you<00:11:48.538> know,<00:11:48.923> the<00:11:49.003> idea<00:11:49.644> of<00:11:50.045> why<00:11:50.237> it<00:11:50.350> helps<00:11:50.542> a<00:11:50.607> homeowner<00:11:51.249> is<00:11:51.988> your<00:11:52.149> house<00:11:52.646> is<00:11:52.855> worth<00:11:53.048> so<00:11:53.369> much<00:11:53.675> more<00:11:54.076> than<00:11:54.221> the<00:11:54.317> land<00:11:54.638> underneath<00:11:55.120> it.

00:11:56.084 --> 00:12:06.171
So<00:11:56.164> if<00:11:56.261> we<00:11:56.389> had<00:11:56.550> a<00:11:56.566> land<00:11:56.807> value<00:11:57.192> tax,<00:11:58.092> the<00:11:58.252> additional<00:11:58.638> tax<00:11:58.879> you'd<00:11:58.975> pay<00:11:59.200> from<00:11:59.377> that<00:11:59.602> would<00:11:59.698> be<00:11:59.794> substantially<00:12:00.726> smaller<00:12:01.529> than<00:12:01.690> the<00:12:01.786> tax<00:12:02.172> savings<00:12:02.670> you'd<00:12:02.830> get<00:12:03.071> from<00:12:03.393> reducing<00:12:04.678> the<00:12:04.822> property<00:12:05.159> tax<00:12:05.545> rate<00:12:05.786> generally.

00:12:06.525 --> 00:12:12.677
So<00:12:06.685> as<00:12:06.846> if<00:12:06.991> we're<00:12:07.232> going<00:12:07.392> back<00:12:07.505> to<00:12:07.569> our<00:12:07.713> Pingree<00:12:08.051> Park<00:12:08.292> example,<00:12:09.737> right<00:12:09.914> now<00:12:10.203> they're<00:12:10.300> paying<00:12:10.958> $4,500<00:12:11.585> in<00:12:11.906> property<00:12:12.227> taxes.

00:12:13.095 --> 00:12:22.664
If<00:12:13.175> we<00:12:13.271> were<00:12:13.352> to<00:12:13.512> eliminate<00:12:13.994> 33<00:12:14.476> mills<00:12:14.861> from<00:12:15.022> the<00:12:15.054> tax<00:12:15.440> bill,<00:12:16.002> they<00:12:16.146> would<00:12:16.307> save<00:12:16.789> $2,200<00:12:18.636> on<00:12:18.813> their<00:12:18.957> main<00:12:19.214> tax<00:12:19.535> bill,<00:12:19.856> and<00:12:19.920> then<00:12:20.016> they'd<00:12:20.177> pay<00:12:20.321> an<00:12:20.434> extra<00:12:20.883> $200<00:12:21.685> in<00:12:21.766> a<00:12:21.782> land<00:12:21.974> value<00:12:22.263> tax.

00:12:23.050 --> 00:12:26.035
Um,<00:12:23.306> so<00:12:23.451> they're<00:12:23.547> still<00:12:23.772> saving,<00:12:24.494> uh,<00:12:24.735> $2,000<00:12:25.794> a<00:12:25.858> year.

00:12:26.821 --> 00:12:29.533
That<00:12:27.383> is<00:12:27.559> like<00:12:27.880> grocery—<00:12:28.298> like,<00:12:28.442> that's<00:12:28.667> like<00:12:28.988> all<00:12:29.020> the<00:12:29.148> groceries.

00:12:29.726 --> 00:12:29.902
Yeah.

00:12:30.833 --> 00:12:30.930
Wow.

00:12:32.037 --> 00:12:34.669
That<00:12:32.679> would<00:12:32.839> have<00:12:33.016> a<00:12:33.080> very<00:12:33.497> large<00:12:33.818> impact<00:12:34.284> on<00:12:34.380> people.

00:12:35.985 --> 00:12:38.344
And<00:12:36.130> so<00:12:36.804> it<00:12:37.028> does—<00:12:37.413> so<00:12:37.574> it<00:12:37.670> does<00:12:37.911> backfill.

00:12:38.553 --> 00:12:40.222
It<00:12:38.729> figured—<00:12:39.436> how<00:12:39.532> does<00:12:39.692> it<00:12:39.821> backfill?

00:12:40.302 --> 00:12:41.297
Because<00:12:40.495> that's<00:12:40.704> the<00:12:40.784> question<00:12:41.057> I<00:12:41.185> have.

00:12:41.345 --> 00:12:44.331
You<00:12:41.426> got<00:12:42.003> this<00:12:42.164> piece<00:12:42.405> of<00:12:42.469> land,<00:12:43.047> you<00:12:43.143> know,<00:12:43.207> a<00:12:43.287> lot<00:12:43.448> of<00:12:43.512> things<00:12:43.769> people<00:12:44.010> need<00:12:44.170> to<00:12:44.250> know.

00:12:44.892 --> 00:12:52.777
And<00:12:45.212> correct<00:12:45.453> me<00:12:45.517> if<00:12:45.549> I'm<00:12:45.773> wrong,<00:12:46.094> Steve,<00:12:46.959> but<00:12:47.055> when<00:12:47.152> you've<00:12:47.280> got<00:12:47.440> a<00:12:47.761> piece<00:12:48.001> of<00:12:48.081> vacant<00:12:48.337> land,<00:12:48.562> you<00:12:48.594> got<00:12:48.722> something<00:12:48.898> out<00:12:49.059> there,<00:12:49.603> oftentimes<00:12:50.325> it's<00:12:50.485> actually<00:12:50.741> costing<00:12:51.286> the<00:12:51.318> city<00:12:51.719> money<00:12:52.023> to<00:12:52.168> take<00:12:52.328> care<00:12:52.584> of<00:12:52.729> it.

00:12:53.402 --> 00:12:58.289
So<00:12:53.546> how<00:12:53.642> do<00:12:53.770> you<00:12:53.866> go<00:12:54.091> from<00:12:54.283> something<00:12:54.652> that's<00:12:54.828> costing<00:12:55.293> the<00:12:55.325> city<00:12:55.629> money<00:12:55.870> to<00:12:56.014> take<00:12:56.174> care<00:12:56.430> of<00:12:56.511> to<00:12:56.607> being<00:12:56.751> like<00:12:57.055> net<00:12:57.392> revenue<00:12:57.793> positive?

00:12:58.354 --> 00:12:59.027
How<00:12:58.434> does<00:12:58.514> that<00:12:58.754> work?

00:12:59.171 --> 00:13:08.065
So,<00:12:59.299> I<00:12:59.331> mean,<00:12:59.475> so<00:12:59.700> one<00:12:59.892> small<00:13:00.261> example<00:13:00.677> is<00:13:00.838> if<00:13:00.902> you<00:13:00.982> take<00:13:01.222> one<00:13:01.318> of<00:13:01.382> those<00:13:01.623> vacant<00:13:01.943> residential<00:13:02.424> parcels<00:13:02.825> we<00:13:02.857> were<00:13:02.985> talking<00:13:03.322> about<00:13:03.482> earlier,<00:13:04.668> they<00:13:04.844> too<00:13:05.068> would<00:13:05.245> pay<00:13:05.501> about<00:13:05.870> $200<00:13:06.591> in<00:13:06.671> taxes<00:13:07.072> on<00:13:07.168> that<00:13:07.392> one<00:13:07.632> parcel.

00:13:08.129 --> 00:13:09.379
Today<00:13:08.450> they're<00:13:08.530> paying<00:13:08.786> about<00:13:09.027> $20.

00:13:09.908 --> 00:13:15.725
So<00:13:10.116> it's—<00:13:10.773> wait,<00:13:11.174> wait,<00:13:11.398> wait,<00:13:12.761> hold<00:13:13.161> on,<00:13:13.562> hold,<00:13:14.155> hold<00:13:14.604> on,<00:13:14.924> hold<00:13:15.245> on,<00:13:15.485> hold<00:13:15.661> on.

00:13:17.330 --> 00:13:18.950
This<00:13:17.602> is<00:13:17.747> incredulous<00:13:18.469> to<00:13:18.645> me.

00:13:20.057 --> 00:13:26.731
Hold<00:13:20.249> on,<00:13:20.779> so<00:13:20.939> somebody<00:13:21.661> who<00:13:21.822> is<00:13:22.142> investing<00:13:22.800> in<00:13:22.880> the<00:13:22.945> city<00:13:23.201> of<00:13:23.281> Detroit—<00:13:23.666> let's—<00:13:24.068> our<00:13:24.228> listeners<00:13:24.629> in<00:13:24.725> Pingree<00:13:25.046> Park,<00:13:25.367> we<00:13:25.511> love<00:13:25.672> you,<00:13:26.073> I<00:13:26.105> know<00:13:26.265> we<00:13:26.394> have<00:13:26.554> some.

00:13:28.158 --> 00:13:41.971
The<00:13:28.255> person<00:13:28.720> who<00:13:28.832> is<00:13:29.057> investing,<00:13:30.164> who<00:13:30.324> is<00:13:30.581> caring,<00:13:31.142> who<00:13:31.303> is<00:13:31.463> like<00:13:32.009> taking<00:13:32.265> care<00:13:32.586> of<00:13:32.650> their<00:13:32.811> thing,<00:13:34.110> is<00:13:34.190> shouldering<00:13:34.816> all<00:13:34.993> this<00:13:35.233> burden,<00:13:35.715> and<00:13:35.795> then<00:13:35.955> somebody<00:13:36.420> who<00:13:36.581> is<00:13:36.741> doing<00:13:37.239> nothing<00:13:38.265> isn't<00:13:38.907> even<00:13:39.228> like<00:13:39.870> paying<00:13:40.431> enough<00:13:40.688> for<00:13:40.864> a<00:13:41.009> decent<00:13:41.570> dinner?

00:13:42.437 --> 00:13:42.967
That's<00:13:42.774> right.

00:13:43.175 --> 00:13:54.272
And,<00:13:43.336> and<00:13:43.738> to<00:13:43.802> your<00:13:43.962> earlier<00:13:44.219> point,<00:13:44.541> the<00:13:44.637> city<00:13:44.958> is<00:13:45.038> spending<00:13:45.681> something<00:13:46.066> like<00:13:46.323> $7.5<00:13:46.965> million<00:13:47.672> a<00:13:47.817> year<00:13:48.009> mowing<00:13:48.539> all<00:13:48.652> the<00:13:48.732> vacant<00:13:49.101> lots<00:13:49.840> and<00:13:49.985> untold<00:13:50.547> extra,<00:13:51.109> um,<00:13:51.285> dealing<00:13:51.607> with,<00:13:51.992> uh,<00:13:52.410> illegally<00:13:52.811> dumped<00:13:53.052> trash<00:13:53.534> and<00:13:53.678> things<00:13:53.871> like<00:13:54.080> that.

00:13:54.481 --> 00:14:06.349
Have<00:13:54.578> you<00:13:54.658> ever<00:13:54.835> seen<00:13:55.043> that<00:13:55.220> animated,<00:13:55.846> uh,<00:13:56.424> GIF<00:13:56.746> or<00:13:56.906> GIF—<00:13:57.211> I<00:13:57.308> forget<00:13:57.629> how<00:13:57.773> to<00:13:57.806> say<00:13:58.030> it—<00:13:58.576> of<00:13:58.673> that<00:13:58.898> guy,<00:13:59.460> uh,<00:13:59.572> it's<00:13:59.717> in<00:13:59.797> the,<00:14:00.102> in<00:14:00.198> the<00:14:00.295> movie<00:14:00.664> Office<00:14:00.985> Space<00:14:01.323> where<00:14:01.403> he<00:14:01.547> just<00:14:01.708> starts<00:14:02.045> throwing<00:14:03.153> like<00:14:03.410> the<00:14:03.651> computer<00:14:04.454> and<00:14:04.534> like<00:14:04.759> throws<00:14:05.096> over<00:14:05.321> his<00:14:05.498> desk<00:14:05.819> and<00:14:05.899> the<00:14:05.980> papers?

00:14:06.686 --> 00:14:09.063
That's<00:14:06.863> kind<00:14:07.168> of,<00:14:07.281> as<00:14:07.425> a<00:14:07.489> Detroit<00:14:07.811> resident,<00:14:08.164> how<00:14:08.308> I<00:14:08.453> feel<00:14:08.630> right<00:14:08.870> now.

00:14:09.336 --> 00:14:10.313
This<00:14:09.496> is<00:14:09.608> infuriating.

00:14:10.554 --> 00:14:19.896
Yeah,<00:14:10.778> I<00:14:10.810> mean,<00:14:10.954> we<00:14:11.034> have<00:14:11.820> an<00:14:11.900> incredibly<00:14:12.541> inequitable<00:14:13.037> situation<00:14:13.694> across<00:14:14.063> the<00:14:14.127> city<00:14:14.463> where<00:14:15.120> people<00:14:15.361> can<00:14:15.521> sit<00:14:15.745> on<00:14:15.906> land,<00:14:16.322> not<00:14:16.563> take<00:14:16.723> care<00:14:16.963> of<00:14:17.107> it,<00:14:17.268> not<00:14:17.444> do<00:14:17.524> something<00:14:17.909> productive<00:14:18.245> with<00:14:18.470> it,<00:14:18.646> which,<00:14:18.950> you<00:14:18.982> know,<00:14:19.367> that's<00:14:19.607> their<00:14:19.767> right.

00:14:19.944 --> 00:14:20.841
They're<00:14:20.088> a<00:14:20.152> property<00:14:20.553> owner.

00:14:21.674 --> 00:14:24.350
But,<00:14:22.075> but<00:14:22.171> they<00:14:22.251> should<00:14:22.572> pay<00:14:23.213> their<00:14:23.373> fair<00:14:23.613> share<00:14:23.838> of<00:14:23.934> taxes.

00:14:24.895 --> 00:14:24.991
Wow.

00:14:25.761 --> 00:14:27.091
Yeah,<00:14:26.337> that's<00:14:26.562> something<00:14:26.722> to<00:14:26.754> think<00:14:26.914> about.

00:14:27.764 --> 00:14:35.567
A<00:14:27.860> lot<00:14:28.036> of<00:14:28.100> people<00:14:28.405> will<00:14:28.645> ask,<00:14:29.462> why<00:14:29.622> don't<00:14:29.927> you<00:14:30.023> just<00:14:30.263> send<00:14:30.728> a<00:14:30.808> bill<00:14:31.209> to<00:14:31.850> Mr.<00:14:32.731> Chris<00:14:33.148> Illich<00:14:33.612> and<00:14:33.869> Dan<00:14:34.173> Gilbert<00:14:34.734> and<00:14:34.894> Roger<00:14:35.231> Penske?

00:14:36.016 --> 00:14:36.128
Right?

00:14:36.192 --> 00:14:40.888
Just<00:14:36.353> say,<00:14:36.497> hey,<00:14:37.619> you're<00:14:38.196> billionaires,<00:14:38.740> you<00:14:38.837> should<00:14:38.997> pay<00:14:39.157> this,<00:14:39.878> like,<00:14:40.039> pay<00:14:40.263> this<00:14:40.439> difference.

00:14:41.882 --> 00:14:46.657
So<00:14:42.426> you,<00:14:42.843> if<00:14:43.164> you<00:14:43.308> do<00:14:43.484> that,<00:14:43.869> you<00:14:43.965> run<00:14:44.125> the<00:14:44.269> risk<00:14:44.622> that<00:14:45.023> they'll<00:14:45.728> just<00:14:46.112> exit<00:14:46.369> the<00:14:46.449> city.

00:14:46.930 --> 00:14:58.132
One<00:14:47.170> thing<00:14:47.651> about<00:14:48.212> these<00:14:48.436> three<00:14:48.693> solutions<00:14:49.237> I<00:14:49.253> proposed<00:14:49.959> is<00:14:50.199> they're<00:14:50.311> specifically<00:14:52.202> adding<00:14:52.779> tax<00:14:53.100> revenues<00:14:53.645> against<00:14:54.141> things<00:14:54.542> that,<00:14:55.327> you<00:14:55.359> know,<00:14:55.439> that<00:14:55.584> are<00:14:56.048> not<00:14:56.289> going<00:14:56.481> to<00:14:56.705> be<00:14:56.802> leaving<00:14:57.106> Detroit<00:14:57.507> anytime<00:14:57.988> soon.

00:14:58.388 --> 00:15:00.247
Like<00:14:58.548> I<00:14:58.564> said<00:14:58.709> earlier,<00:14:59.045> the<00:14:59.173> land<00:14:59.494> can't<00:14:59.670> go<00:14:59.895> anywhere.

00:15:00.712 --> 00:15:06.209
The<00:15:00.792> casinos<00:15:01.738> are—<00:15:02.218> Detroit's<00:15:02.539> three<00:15:02.635> casinos<00:15:03.036> are<00:15:03.100> the<00:15:03.180> only<00:15:03.661> non-tribal<00:15:04.142> casinos<00:15:04.702> legally<00:15:05.039> allowed<00:15:05.424> to<00:15:05.520> be<00:15:05.664> in<00:15:05.760> Michigan.

00:15:06.786 --> 00:15:11.019
And<00:15:06.882> then<00:15:07.283> our<00:15:07.443> sports<00:15:07.684> and<00:15:07.828> entertainment<00:15:08.245> district<00:15:08.951> is,<00:15:09.191> is<00:15:09.352> unique<00:15:09.993> in,<00:15:10.250> in<00:15:10.330> downtown<00:15:10.650> Detroit.

00:15:11.116 --> 00:15:12.831
All<00:15:11.228> 4<00:15:11.452> major<00:15:11.757> sports<00:15:12.094> teams<00:15:12.414> are<00:15:12.495> there.

00:15:12.896 --> 00:15:15.269
Major<00:15:13.216> concert<00:15:13.617> venues<00:15:13.954> are<00:15:14.098> there<00:15:14.579> in<00:15:14.740> arenas.

00:15:15.926 --> 00:15:18.700
Um,<00:15:16.022> that's<00:15:16.279> not<00:15:16.488> something<00:15:16.985> that<00:15:17.289> is<00:15:17.386> going<00:15:17.498> to<00:15:17.546> pick<00:15:17.770> up<00:15:17.883> and<00:15:18.091> move<00:15:18.332> overnight.

00:15:19.294 --> 00:15:21.202
Well,<00:15:19.470> and<00:15:19.630> also<00:15:19.887> these<00:15:20.112> are<00:15:20.192> business<00:15:20.577> operations.

00:15:21.699 --> 00:15:28.065
One<00:15:21.876> thing<00:15:22.180> that<00:15:22.501> I,<00:15:22.757> uh,<00:15:23.223> learned<00:15:23.944> is<00:15:24.121> that,<00:15:24.425> you<00:15:24.505> know,<00:15:24.682> unlike<00:15:25.002> New<00:15:25.147> York<00:15:25.339> City,<00:15:26.125> none<00:15:26.285> of<00:15:26.349> these<00:15:26.526> guys<00:15:26.831> actually<00:15:27.151> live<00:15:27.312> in<00:15:27.344> the<00:15:27.424> city<00:15:27.632> of<00:15:27.729> Detroit.

00:15:28.610 --> 00:15:33.213
Whereas,<00:15:29.076> you<00:15:29.108> know,<00:15:29.268> like<00:15:29.428> in<00:15:29.492> New<00:15:29.637> York<00:15:29.813> City,<00:15:30.118> you've<00:15:30.294> got<00:15:30.679> like,<00:15:31.016> I<00:15:31.096> don't<00:15:31.176> know,<00:15:31.401> 150-some<00:15:32.299> billionaires<00:15:32.844> who<00:15:32.940> live<00:15:33.117> here.

00:15:33.662 --> 00:15:34.706
I<00:15:33.742> believe<00:15:34.047> we<00:15:34.208> have<00:15:34.401> zero.

00:15:35.573 --> 00:15:35.958
That's<00:15:35.734> correct.

00:15:36.007 --> 00:15:40.600
I<00:15:36.055> mean,<00:15:36.617> you<00:15:36.778> know,<00:15:36.938> right<00:15:37.115> now,<00:15:37.757> you<00:15:37.854> know,<00:15:37.918> the<00:15:38.078> only<00:15:38.303> thing<00:15:38.480> they<00:15:38.576> might<00:15:38.801> be<00:15:38.946> paying<00:15:39.267> on<00:15:39.460> is<00:15:39.668> property<00:15:40.086> they<00:15:40.230> own<00:15:40.471> here.

00:15:40.873 --> 00:15:52.291
And<00:15:40.969> if,<00:15:41.290> and<00:15:41.435> if<00:15:41.547> it's<00:15:41.756> not<00:15:42.013> economical<00:15:42.495> for<00:15:42.607> them<00:15:42.736> to<00:15:42.896> continue<00:15:43.844> holding<00:15:44.101> that<00:15:44.261> property<00:15:44.583> or<00:15:44.663> investing<00:15:45.064> in<00:15:45.145> that<00:15:45.305> property,<00:15:45.627> or<00:15:45.707> they<00:15:45.739> don't<00:15:45.835> have<00:15:45.932> an<00:15:45.964> incentive<00:15:46.590> to<00:15:46.654> invest<00:15:47.072> in<00:15:47.152> that<00:15:47.313> property,<00:15:48.758> where<00:15:48.999> we<00:15:49.240> continue<00:15:49.641> to<00:15:49.786> see<00:15:50.348> less<00:15:50.605> revenue<00:15:50.942> from<00:15:51.247> those<00:15:51.488> exact<00:15:51.745> same<00:15:51.970> folks.

00:15:52.532 --> 00:15:54.668
So<00:15:52.709> we<00:15:52.837> hold<00:15:53.094> less<00:15:53.319> cards<00:15:53.737> maybe<00:15:53.978> than<00:15:54.074> some<00:15:54.299> places.

00:15:55.423 --> 00:15:56.033
Interesting.

00:15:56.531 --> 00:15:56.997
Interesting.

00:15:57.928 --> 00:16:03.018
So<00:15:58.057> as<00:15:58.153> far<00:15:58.234> as<00:15:58.314> making<00:15:58.555> some<00:15:58.715> of<00:15:58.780> these<00:15:59.037> things<00:15:59.261> happen,<00:15:59.599> I<00:15:59.663> imagine<00:16:00.000> there's<00:16:00.787> various<00:16:01.204> steps<00:16:01.686> and<00:16:01.766> pieces<00:16:02.151> that<00:16:02.232> need<00:16:02.360> to<00:16:02.473> come<00:16:02.649> into<00:16:02.810> place.

00:16:03.757 --> 00:16:04.303
What<00:16:03.933> would<00:16:04.030> it<00:16:04.158> take?

00:16:05.137 --> 00:16:09.119
So<00:16:05.378> it<00:16:05.523> will,<00:16:06.165> and<00:16:06.422> for<00:16:06.727> on<00:16:06.823> all<00:16:06.968> three<00:16:07.144> fronts,<00:16:07.481> it<00:16:07.545> will<00:16:07.706> take<00:16:08.091> action<00:16:08.653> in<00:16:08.749> Lansing.

00:16:09.729 --> 00:16:17.065
So<00:16:10.355> one<00:16:10.580> key<00:16:10.676> point<00:16:10.981> that<00:16:11.077> a<00:16:11.141> lot<00:16:11.302> of<00:16:11.382> folks<00:16:11.864> may<00:16:11.960> not<00:16:12.185> realize,<00:16:12.683> and<00:16:12.779> I<00:16:12.795> totally<00:16:13.004> understand<00:16:13.405> why<00:16:13.501> not,<00:16:13.951> is<00:16:14.850> Detroit<00:16:15.251> can't<00:16:15.492> just<00:16:15.717> create<00:16:16.070> its<00:16:16.214> own<00:16:16.375> new<00:16:16.535> taxes.

00:16:17.322 --> 00:16:19.072
That's<00:16:17.563> actually<00:16:17.820> true<00:16:18.061> in<00:16:18.205> some<00:16:18.446> parts<00:16:18.622> of<00:16:18.687> the<00:16:18.783> country.

00:16:19.425 --> 00:16:24.867
Michigan<00:16:20.388> tightly<00:16:20.870> restricts<00:16:22.459> local<00:16:22.716> tax<00:16:23.679> policy<00:16:24.016> and<00:16:24.081> taxing<00:16:24.466> authority.

00:16:24.964 --> 00:16:28.959
We<00:16:25.044> can<00:16:25.204> only<00:16:26.071> raise<00:16:26.248> taxes<00:16:26.890> that<00:16:27.452> a<00:16:27.468> state<00:16:27.772> law<00:16:28.013> authorizes<00:16:28.494> us<00:16:28.574> to<00:16:28.735> do.

00:16:29.216 --> 00:16:33.754
That's<00:16:29.376> why<00:16:29.472> so<00:16:29.713> many<00:16:29.857> cities<00:16:30.258> in<00:16:30.338> Michigan,<00:16:30.675> including<00:16:31.012> Detroit,<00:16:31.846> rely<00:16:32.102> so<00:16:32.327> heavily<00:16:32.728> on<00:16:32.888> property<00:16:33.225> taxes.

00:16:34.171 --> 00:16:36.159
We<00:16:34.219> don't<00:16:34.411> have<00:16:34.989> a<00:16:35.069> basket<00:16:35.486> of<00:16:35.614> options.

00:16:36.432 --> 00:16:42.606
So<00:16:36.576> what<00:16:36.672> we'd<00:16:36.753> be<00:16:36.913> asking<00:16:37.234> Lansing<00:16:37.715> to<00:16:37.795> do<00:16:37.939> is<00:16:38.116> give<00:16:38.276> us<00:16:38.436> more<00:16:38.661> options,<00:16:39.623> and,<00:16:40.024> and<00:16:40.120> that<00:16:40.264> would<00:16:40.345> include<00:16:41.387> all<00:16:41.467> three<00:16:41.708> items<00:16:41.948> we<00:16:42.028> talked<00:16:42.301> about.

00:16:42.990 --> 00:16:45.251
Folks<00:16:43.167> have<00:16:43.311> often<00:16:43.568> talked<00:16:43.872> too<00:16:44.049> about<00:16:44.289> a<00:16:44.305> sales<00:16:44.770> tax.

00:16:45.572 --> 00:16:52.788
That<00:16:45.893> right<00:16:46.053> now<00:16:46.534> would<00:16:46.679> require<00:16:47.015> an<00:16:47.096> amendment<00:16:47.480> to<00:16:47.561> the<00:16:47.641> state<00:16:47.897> constitution<00:16:49.180> because<00:16:49.565> we've<00:16:49.725> hardwired<00:16:50.607> in<00:16:51.425> the<00:16:51.570> current<00:16:51.842> sales<00:16:52.227> tax<00:16:52.532> rate.

00:16:53.109 --> 00:17:00.102
I'd<00:16:53.253> also<00:16:53.526> argue<00:16:54.151> if<00:16:54.232> we<00:16:54.312> were<00:16:54.408> to<00:16:54.472> have<00:16:54.697> just<00:16:54.969> a<00:16:55.017> city-specific<00:16:55.771> sales<00:16:56.076> tax,<00:16:56.461> we<00:16:56.621> run<00:16:56.717> the<00:16:56.861> risk<00:16:57.262> that<00:16:57.679> you're<00:16:57.840> just<00:16:57.984> going<00:16:58.048> to<00:16:58.144> shift<00:16:58.738> sales<00:16:59.107> activity<00:16:59.508> outside<00:16:59.765> the<00:16:59.846> city.

00:17:00.327 --> 00:17:10.587
And<00:17:00.472> when<00:17:00.568> I've<00:17:00.713> seen<00:17:00.970> sales<00:17:01.291> tax<00:17:01.692> implemented<00:17:02.238> in<00:17:02.479> other<00:17:02.655> places,<00:17:03.073> especially<00:17:03.619> for<00:17:03.876> shared<00:17:04.245> services—<00:17:04.727> like,<00:17:05.626> specifically,<00:17:06.573> one<00:17:06.750> thing<00:17:06.910> that<00:17:07.055> holds<00:17:07.392> back,<00:17:07.938> uh,<00:17:08.340> transit<00:17:08.757> funding<00:17:09.480> is<00:17:09.640> a<00:17:09.720> lack<00:17:09.961> of<00:17:10.025> sales<00:17:10.282> tax.

00:17:10.925 --> 00:17:18.648
But<00:17:11.005> that<00:17:11.246> sales<00:17:11.631> tax<00:17:11.968> would<00:17:12.273> be<00:17:13.012> implemented<00:17:13.815> across<00:17:14.441> the<00:17:14.553> entire<00:17:15.083> transit<00:17:15.517> service<00:17:16.207> area,<00:17:17.171> as<00:17:17.331> opposed<00:17:17.733> to<00:17:17.893> just<00:17:18.214> one<00:17:18.391> city.

00:17:18.712 --> 00:17:26.596
Because<00:17:18.953> here,<00:17:19.675> especially<00:17:20.221> as<00:17:20.318> we're<00:17:20.494> such<00:17:20.799> a<00:17:20.880> polycentric<00:17:21.506> region,<00:17:22.245> there's<00:17:22.485> a<00:17:22.550> lot<00:17:22.710> of<00:17:22.790> people<00:17:23.031> who<00:17:23.192> just<00:17:23.369> go,<00:17:23.674> oh,<00:17:23.706> I'll<00:17:23.995> just<00:17:24.509> I'll<00:17:24.653> just<00:17:25.119> put<00:17:25.295> my—<00:17:25.520> you<00:17:25.616> know,<00:17:25.697> I<00:17:25.777> think<00:17:25.922> about<00:17:26.162> this<00:17:26.323> all<00:17:26.355> the<00:17:26.403> time.

00:17:26.644 --> 00:17:34.175
Yeah,<00:17:27.206> all<00:17:27.238> those<00:17:27.688> businesses<00:17:28.185> that<00:17:28.282> are<00:17:28.410> on<00:17:28.507> like<00:17:28.667> one<00:17:28.844> side<00:17:29.133> of<00:17:29.165> the<00:17:29.229> Grosse<00:17:29.550> Pointe<00:17:29.791> border<00:17:30.032> on<00:17:30.128> the<00:17:30.273> east<00:17:30.466> side<00:17:31.140> and<00:17:31.220> then<00:17:31.557> one<00:17:31.702> on<00:17:31.814> the<00:17:32.023> other<00:17:32.200> side<00:17:33.002> and<00:17:33.067> they<00:17:33.147> have<00:17:33.308> completely<00:17:33.629> different<00:17:33.870> rates.

00:17:34.865 --> 00:17:36.808
It's<00:17:35.234> very<00:17:35.572> easy<00:17:35.812> in<00:17:35.893> this<00:17:36.037> region<00:17:36.358> to<00:17:36.455> do<00:17:36.615> that.

00:17:37.177 --> 00:17:42.283
Yeah,<00:17:37.739> I<00:17:37.755> mean,<00:17:38.060> a<00:17:38.205> great<00:17:38.381> principle<00:17:38.847> of<00:17:38.927> public<00:17:39.200> finance<00:17:39.746> is<00:17:39.891> that<00:17:40.148> regional<00:17:40.549> assets<00:17:41.031> should<00:17:41.191> have<00:17:41.512> regional<00:17:41.850> funding.

00:17:42.781 --> 00:17:49.589
And<00:17:43.279> the<00:17:43.359> voters<00:17:43.760> just<00:17:43.921> spoke<00:17:44.306> and<00:17:44.403> did<00:17:44.627> just<00:17:44.804> that<00:17:45.109> with<00:17:46.410> both<00:17:46.586> historical<00:17:47.052> museums<00:17:47.775> just<00:17:47.935> this<00:17:48.080> past<00:17:48.256> November,<00:17:48.658> which<00:17:48.818> is<00:17:48.915> amazing<00:17:49.300> news.

00:17:49.926 --> 00:17:58.149
You<00:17:49.958> know,<00:17:50.246> and<00:17:50.343> so<00:17:51.128> any<00:17:51.288> chance<00:17:51.545> we<00:17:51.689> have<00:17:52.346> to<00:17:52.811> have<00:17:52.988> the<00:17:53.212> region<00:17:53.549> invest<00:17:53.933> together<00:17:54.350> in<00:17:54.446> such<00:17:54.751> things<00:17:55.232> is<00:17:55.344> not<00:17:55.649> only<00:17:55.953> a<00:17:56.033> benefit<00:17:56.418> to<00:17:56.498> Detroit,<00:17:56.995> but<00:17:57.155> a<00:17:57.236> benefit<00:17:57.540> to<00:17:57.636> the<00:17:57.716> region<00:17:57.957> as<00:17:58.053> a<00:17:58.085> whole.

00:17:58.662 --> 00:18:06.068
You<00:17:58.710> know,<00:17:58.774> speaking<00:17:59.111> about<00:17:59.239> Lansing<00:17:59.656> and<00:17:59.784> regionally,<00:18:00.185> though,<00:18:00.506> if<00:18:00.602> we<00:18:00.746> talk<00:18:01.003> about<00:18:01.243> an<00:18:01.403> LVT,<00:18:01.804> how<00:18:01.932> would<00:18:02.045> that<00:18:02.830> maybe<00:18:03.391> or<00:18:03.423> maybe<00:18:03.744> not<00:18:04.129> impact<00:18:05.491> other<00:18:05.812> cities?

00:18:06.116 --> 00:18:09.242
Because<00:18:06.277> I<00:18:06.293> know<00:18:06.517> you<00:18:06.677> work<00:18:06.854> with<00:18:07.094> other<00:18:07.719> places<00:18:08.152> around<00:18:08.601> the<00:18:08.697> state.

00:18:10.220 --> 00:18:11.454
Does<00:18:10.444> it<00:18:10.605> give<00:18:10.781> them<00:18:10.941> the<00:18:11.166> option?

00:18:11.502 --> 00:18:13.154
Does<00:18:11.679> it<00:18:11.759> force<00:18:12.224> them<00:18:12.384> into<00:18:12.705> anything?

00:18:13.266 --> 00:18:14.965
I'm—<00:18:13.891> I<00:18:13.907> apologize<00:18:14.452> for<00:18:14.548> my<00:18:14.708> question.

00:18:15.093 --> 00:18:17.129
No,<00:18:15.286> no,<00:18:15.494> you're<00:18:16.087> spot<00:18:16.456> on<00:18:16.552> with<00:18:17.033> this.

00:18:17.177 --> 00:18:21.489
Was<00:18:17.273> part<00:18:17.514> of<00:18:17.594> the<00:18:17.674> debate<00:18:18.139> 3<00:18:18.315> years<00:18:18.572> ago<00:18:18.876> was<00:18:19.918> would<00:18:20.063> this<00:18:20.239> be<00:18:20.399> a<00:18:20.479> Detroit-only<00:18:21.281> thing?

00:18:21.746 --> 00:18:23.642
Would<00:18:21.907> it<00:18:22.067> be<00:18:22.405> a<00:18:22.485> statewide<00:18:23.192> option?

00:18:24.156 --> 00:18:29.201
You<00:18:24.204> know,<00:18:24.268> certainly<00:18:25.441> I<00:18:25.618> think<00:18:25.939> it<00:18:26.084> should<00:18:26.180> be<00:18:26.743> an<00:18:26.967> option<00:18:27.289> available<00:18:27.626> to<00:18:27.787> any<00:18:27.947> local<00:18:28.253> community<00:18:28.670> that<00:18:28.831> wants<00:18:29.152> it.

00:18:29.474 --> 00:18:34.342
It<00:18:29.554> might<00:18:29.651> not<00:18:29.875> be<00:18:30.020> a<00:18:30.100> good<00:18:30.277> fit<00:18:30.582> everywhere,<00:18:31.305> but<00:18:31.562> that<00:18:31.723> should<00:18:31.964> be<00:18:32.189> up<00:18:32.301> for<00:18:32.430> each<00:18:32.671> local<00:18:32.848> community<00:18:33.330> to<00:18:33.490> decide<00:18:33.812> for<00:18:33.892> themselves.

00:18:34.519 --> 00:18:42.536
And<00:18:34.679> if<00:18:34.776> Lansing<00:18:35.177> were<00:18:35.258> to<00:18:35.483> authorize<00:18:36.639> new<00:18:36.848> local<00:18:37.105> taxes<00:18:37.571> like<00:18:37.732> a<00:18:37.748> land<00:18:37.925> value<00:18:38.230> tax<00:18:38.632> or<00:18:38.712> the<00:18:39.033> entertainment<00:18:39.515> tax,<00:18:40.720> the<00:18:40.800> local<00:18:41.122> voters<00:18:41.507> would<00:18:41.588> have<00:18:41.748> to<00:18:41.829> vote<00:18:42.070> on<00:18:42.166> it<00:18:42.311> too.

00:18:43.210 --> 00:18:48.239
And<00:18:43.355> so<00:18:43.853> the<00:18:44.014> public<00:18:44.335> would<00:18:44.480> get<00:18:44.640> a<00:18:44.656> chance<00:18:45.058> to<00:18:45.203> weigh<00:18:45.444> in<00:18:46.327> after<00:18:46.665> Lansing<00:18:47.227> passes<00:18:47.548> such<00:18:47.805> legislation.

00:18:48.448 --> 00:18:56.328
So<00:18:48.657> even<00:18:48.817> if<00:18:48.913> Lansing<00:18:49.395> does<00:18:49.716> pass<00:18:50.021> something,<00:18:50.984> each<00:18:51.240> local<00:18:51.642> municipality,<00:18:52.524> including<00:18:53.006> Detroit,<00:18:53.391> I<00:18:53.487> would<00:18:53.584> assume,<00:18:54.611> would<00:18:54.755> have<00:18:54.948> to<00:18:55.092> then<00:18:55.253> make<00:18:55.493> a<00:18:55.558> choice<00:18:55.895> and<00:18:56.039> opt<00:18:56.216> in,.

00:18:56.601 --> 00:18:56.793
Right?

00:18:56.842 --> 00:19:11.189
And<00:18:56.922> so<00:18:57.002> you<00:18:57.098> could<00:18:57.243> see<00:18:57.564> a<00:18:57.821> potential<00:18:58.302> timeline<00:18:59.008> of<00:18:59.409> if<00:18:59.506> Lansing<00:18:59.891> were<00:19:00.051> to<00:19:00.212> act<00:19:00.453> on<00:19:00.613> a<00:19:00.629> proposal<00:19:01.175> like<00:19:01.416> this<00:19:01.737> this<00:19:01.929> year,<00:19:02.619> Detroiters<00:19:03.117> could<00:19:03.518> vote<00:19:03.743> on<00:19:04.336> new<00:19:04.625> local<00:19:04.866> tax<00:19:05.123> proposals<00:19:05.685> in<00:19:05.765> 2028,<00:19:07.033> uh,<00:19:07.209> we<00:19:07.257> could<00:19:07.370> implement<00:19:07.691> them<00:19:07.771> in<00:19:07.851> 2029<00:19:08.589> and<00:19:08.670> start<00:19:08.975> seeing<00:19:09.440> some<00:19:09.617> tax<00:19:10.002> relief<00:19:10.339> in<00:19:10.499> just<00:19:10.644> a<00:19:10.660> few<00:19:10.901> years.

00:19:11.783 --> 00:19:14.078
Fascinating<00:19:12.505> stuff,<00:19:13.163> Steve<00:19:13.549> Watson.

00:19:14.271 --> 00:19:18.974
Uh,<00:19:14.993> I<00:19:15.073> love<00:19:15.298> getting<00:19:15.475> into<00:19:15.651> the<00:19:15.716> nitty-gritty<00:19:16.277> about<00:19:16.502> how<00:19:16.614> we<00:19:16.743> could<00:19:16.984> actually<00:19:17.305> make<00:19:17.545> things<00:19:17.786> more<00:19:17.899> affordable<00:19:18.348> for<00:19:18.460> Detroiters.

00:19:19.022 --> 00:19:19.263
Yeah,.

00:19:19.472 --> 00:19:26.198
I<00:19:19.504> mean,<00:19:19.648> we've<00:19:19.809> been<00:19:19.905> stuck<00:19:20.274> in,<00:19:20.692> in<00:19:20.756> this<00:19:20.916> high<00:19:21.093> property<00:19:21.414> tax<00:19:21.719> rate<00:19:21.960> mode<00:19:22.281> for<00:19:22.538> decades<00:19:22.875> and<00:19:23.019> decades<00:19:23.661> without<00:19:24.143> any<00:19:24.448> obvious<00:19:24.801> solutions<00:19:25.267> because<00:19:25.748> there<00:19:25.989> aren't.

00:19:26.294 --> 00:19:37.916
They<00:19:26.454> require<00:19:27.289> some<00:19:27.434> creative<00:19:27.835> thinking,<00:19:28.397> new<00:19:28.557> ideas,<00:19:29.183> and<00:19:29.456> new<00:19:29.841> revenue<00:19:30.179> sources<00:19:30.789> to<00:19:30.869> help<00:19:31.045> us<00:19:31.190> pay<00:19:31.366> for<00:19:31.463> the<00:19:31.527> public<00:19:31.832> services<00:19:32.474> Detroiters<00:19:32.972> need,<00:19:33.999> you<00:19:34.047> know,<00:19:34.176> while<00:19:34.561> also,<00:19:35.042> you<00:19:35.074> know,<00:19:35.219> not<00:19:35.524> shifting<00:19:35.861> all<00:19:35.957> of<00:19:36.022> that<00:19:36.262> burden<00:19:36.648> onto<00:19:36.888> those<00:19:37.065> very<00:19:37.241> same<00:19:37.466> Detroiters.

00:19:38.333 --> 00:19:44.849
Well,<00:19:38.590> Steve<00:19:38.911> Watson<00:19:39.778> at<00:19:40.019> Watson<00:19:40.340> and<00:19:40.420> Yates,<00:19:40.677> you<00:19:40.741> can<00:19:40.837> check<00:19:41.142> out<00:19:41.383> all<00:19:41.495> of<00:19:41.543> his<00:19:41.640> writing<00:19:42.346> at<00:19:42.587> The<00:19:42.763> Balanced<00:19:43.485> Sheet<00:19:44.287> Substack.

00:19:44.993 --> 00:19:50.945
As<00:19:45.154> always,<00:19:45.426> if<00:19:45.555> you've<00:19:45.715> got<00:19:45.891> questions<00:19:46.309> or<00:19:46.453> things,<00:19:47.191> send<00:19:47.416> them<00:19:47.576> along<00:19:47.897> dailydetroit@gmail.com,<00:19:49.244> 313-789-3211.

00:19:51.346 --> 00:19:55.196
If<00:19:51.426> you've<00:19:51.507> got<00:19:51.731> specific<00:19:52.212> questions<00:19:52.630> too,<00:19:52.870> I'm<00:19:53.031> sure,<00:19:53.191> Steve,<00:19:53.448> you're<00:19:53.672> open<00:19:53.865> to<00:19:54.057> having<00:19:54.298> a<00:19:54.378> conversation<00:19:54.940> about<00:19:55.116> them.

00:19:55.582 --> 00:20:00.170
Oh<00:19:55.598> yeah,<00:19:55.678> I<00:19:55.838> mean,<00:19:56.079> you<00:19:56.223> can<00:19:56.480> get<00:19:56.576> in<00:19:56.640> touch<00:19:56.881> with<00:19:57.025> us<00:19:57.122> anytime,<00:19:57.828> uh,<00:19:58.004> through<00:19:58.164> our<00:19:58.309> website<00:19:58.886> watsonyates.com.

00:20:00.555 --> 00:20:03.699
All<00:20:00.587> right,<00:20:00.972> well,<00:20:01.116> thank<00:20:01.293> you<00:20:01.389> so<00:20:01.630> much,<00:20:01.919> Steve,<00:20:02.175> for<00:20:02.352> stopping<00:20:02.657> by<00:20:02.817> the<00:20:02.881> studio<00:20:03.202> at<00:20:03.282> Tech<00:20:03.459> Town.

00:20:03.860 --> 00:20:04.261
Thanks,<00:20:04.100> Jer.

00:20:04.726 --> 00:20:05.945
All<00:20:04.758> right,<00:20:04.967> that<00:20:05.127> is<00:20:05.368> it<00:20:05.480> for<00:20:05.705> today.

00:20:06.042 --> 00:20:08.207
Thank<00:20:06.250> you<00:20:06.330> so<00:20:06.603> much<00:20:06.892> for<00:20:06.988> listening<00:20:07.373> to<00:20:07.453> your<00:20:07.550> Daily<00:20:07.854> Detroit.

00:20:08.496 --> 00:20:09.765
I<00:20:08.512> hope<00:20:08.753> you<00:20:08.818> got<00:20:08.978> something<00:20:09.251> out<00:20:09.299> of<00:20:09.460> this<00:20:09.636> one.

00:20:09.941 --> 00:20:11.338
I<00:20:10.118> did<00:20:10.760> for<00:20:10.921> sure.

00:20:11.965 --> 00:20:14.212
We<00:20:12.109> got<00:20:12.366> nerdy,<00:20:12.848> but<00:20:12.992> thank<00:20:13.169> you<00:20:13.249> for<00:20:13.410> sticking<00:20:13.795> with<00:20:13.972> us.

00:20:14.598 --> 00:20:15.657
You<00:20:14.678> know<00:20:14.839> who<00:20:14.935> else<00:20:15.128> sticks<00:20:15.336> with<00:20:15.513> us?

00:20:15.722 --> 00:20:17.102
Our<00:20:15.834> members<00:20:16.444> on<00:20:16.621> Patreon.

00:20:17.488 --> 00:20:20.137
Local<00:20:17.745> media<00:20:18.146> needs<00:20:18.788> local<00:20:19.093> support<00:20:19.431> to<00:20:19.527> survive<00:20:19.848> and<00:20:19.912> thrive.

00:20:20.458 --> 00:20:21.325
You<00:20:20.506> know<00:20:20.571> what<00:20:20.699> I'd<00:20:20.779> love<00:20:20.956> to<00:20:21.036> see?

00:20:21.582 --> 00:20:27.330
I'd<00:20:21.743> love<00:20:21.919> to<00:20:22.000> be<00:20:22.176> able<00:20:22.305> to<00:20:22.401> put<00:20:22.562> together<00:20:22.963> $2,000<00:20:24.392> for<00:20:24.552> Daily<00:20:24.825> Detroit<00:20:25.676> right<00:20:25.853> around<00:20:26.174> our<00:20:26.335> 2,000th<00:20:26.977> episode.

00:20:27.394 --> 00:20:31.970
It<00:20:27.427> would<00:20:27.539> be<00:20:27.635> a<00:20:27.764> great<00:20:28.197> thing<00:20:28.888> because<00:20:29.225> we<00:20:29.369> would<00:20:29.530> just<00:20:29.787> invest<00:20:30.172> it<00:20:30.333> right<00:20:30.670> into<00:20:31.232> our<00:20:31.457> local<00:20:31.713> coverage.

00:20:32.019 --> 00:20:37.469
There's<00:20:32.179> so<00:20:32.275> many<00:20:32.436> things<00:20:33.142> that<00:20:33.223> just<00:20:33.480> a<00:20:33.560> few<00:20:33.865> bucks<00:20:34.106> more<00:20:34.365> could<00:20:34.608> do<00:20:35.254> for<00:20:35.497> the<00:20:35.577> show<00:20:36.208> and<00:20:36.450> for<00:20:36.628> what<00:20:36.790> we<00:20:36.951> do<00:20:37.178> out<00:20:37.339> here.

00:20:37.695 --> 00:20:39.829
So<00:20:38.309> become<00:20:38.568> a<00:20:38.584> member,<00:20:38.891> patreon.com/dailydetroit.

00:20:41.010 --> 00:20:47.591
We've<00:20:41.090> got<00:20:41.187> sticker<00:20:41.446> packs<00:20:42.319> and<00:20:42.481> a<00:20:42.513> whole<00:20:42.804> lot<00:20:43.047> more,<00:20:43.225> as<00:20:43.387> well<00:20:43.694> as<00:20:43.856> a<00:20:44.098> very<00:20:44.357> special<00:20:44.907> gift<00:20:45.473> coming<00:20:45.812> to<00:20:45.974> you<00:20:46.524> for<00:20:47.106> December.

00:20:47.914 --> 00:20:49.742
With<00:20:48.060> that,<00:20:48.383> I<00:20:48.788> am<00:20:49.030> Jer<00:20:49.305> Stays.

00:20:49.839 --> 00:20:50.922
Thank<00:20:50.017> you<00:20:50.081> so<00:20:50.356> much<00:20:50.470> for<00:20:50.583> listening.

00:20:50.987 --> 00:20:54.316
Remember<00:20:51.391> that<00:20:51.536> you<00:20:51.698> are<00:20:51.795> somebody,<00:20:52.522> and<00:20:52.587> we'll<00:20:52.765> see<00:20:52.926> you<00:20:53.411> around<00:20:53.799> Detroit.

```